Macedoniae acta archaeologica 20 (2011) · стр. 91–124
Аналитички преглед на македонскиот неолит
Содржина
Up to the present time, three main groups of opinions have come to clarify the origin, evolution and dating of the Neolithic on Macedonian territory: the ones led by Josip KoroSec,1 by Milutin GaraSanin?2 and by Marija Gimbutas.3
First, we shall focus on the excavations of J. KoroSec, as his results were issued earlier than the other two.
Josip Коговес divides the discoveries from Anzabegovo (Barutnica) into three phases. He views the first of these phases as the earliest phase of the Macedonian Neolithic. By means of the painted ceramic from the lower levels, he shows that the first phase is descended from the Thessalian groups.4 He considers the painting with floral aspects to be Proto-Sesklo, and correlates the ceramic decorated in impresso style with the discoveries from Nea Nikomedeia I or Proto-Sesklo, Sesklo, while also agreeing with the theory of the Egeo-Thessalian origin of the Macedonian Neolithic.
The second group of opinions is centered around Milutin GaraSanin, who considers the discoveries from Tarinci, VrSnik®5 site, from the first chronological stage (Vrsnik 1-П), to be discoveries with a strong Thessalo-Thracic character, while he considers the fourth phase as being the beginning stage of the Balkan-Anatholian Chalcholithic. Later on, he dismisses this theory in favor of the theory of Stojan Ditrijevi¢é who, on the basis of the discoveries from Lepenski Vir, issues the theory regarding the local development of all Staréevo®6 attributes. Before his death, he comes back to his old theory about the Egeo-Thessalian origin of the Macedonian Neolithic.
Marija Gimbutas speculates that the early stages of development from the Neolithic site of Anzabegovo Ia-b, are closer to the Thraco-Thessalian cultures considering that the white on red painting, the flat pots and the pink burning color (pink-buff — skin color) are discoveries also
Korošec P.-Korošec J. [1960]1973. present at Nea Nikomedeia. Thus, these characteristics are correlated with the Staréevian space, more precisely with the discoveries from Donja Branjevina, Rudnik and Gura Baciului. She correlates the second phase, Anzabegovo II, with Servia V, Crnokalatka Bara, Bubanj, Gladnice, Divostin, Staréevo Па, Obrez based on the brown on orange painting and barbotine. The next phase, Anzabegovo III, is associated by Marija Gimbutas with Staréevo IIb, Vinéa Al, Тебе, Perieni, Liubcova, Obre, Gornja Tuzla VI, drawing the attention in this case to the brown on orange painting and to the geometrical motifs. On the basis of blacktopped pottery, she correlates the fourth phase (Anzabegovo IV) with Vintéa B1. However, because of the pottery7 with the curvilinear painted motives, she chronologically links the rest with Vinéa B2/C, due to the pottery handles with buttons she correlates it with Sitagroi, Karanovo III/IV and taking into consideration the cups she associates it with Karanovo-Veselinovo III/IV. Thus, the second period of development, Anzabegovo II-III, as Marija Gimbutas insisted, would have suffered a Staréevization of the elements.8
Another perspective regarding the events that happened in the Neolithization process of the Balkans is now sustained by Gheorghe Lazarovici. On the basis of well structured results following a profound study of the distribution and comparisons of archaeological analysis of the common elements of the early Neolithic cultures, he proposed a more complex chronological system for the stations and groups that develop in parallel with the Star%evo-Cris culture.
Analyzing the issue from the point of view of successive migrations, Gh. Lazarovici divides the periodizations of the Star¢evo-Cris (SC) culture into four stages of migration with multiple subphases of development, leading to four phases with multiple stages: SC IA, SC IB, SC IC, SC ПА, SC IIB, SC IIIA, SC IIIB, SC IVA, IVB9 which develop in parallel with the stations that are part of this culture as well as with the groups from Macedonia. Terms like Ic/IIA, ШАВ and others are used for some of the insufficiently published or dated phenomena, stations and groups.
Pottery Evolution
Because there are numerous contradictions between the before mentioned chronological systems regarding the datation of some stations or the etno-cultural processes (migration, diffusion, routes of entry, cultural or archeological mixtures), we have considered that the advantages offered by the analytical archaeology are more neutral, in the sense of keeping sides of one or another group of researchers, reflecting in fact, the publication stage of the selective materials. In the following lines, we will focus our attention upon the evolution of the Neolithic cultures analyzing the different attributes of the material culture, as much as was offered by the different publications. We mention that we did not have access to the actual material, most of it not being published, from the point of view of analytical archaeology.
In order to accomplish this we have completed a database, containing information upon the Neolithic stations from the Balkan countries, having around 37000 records. Almost everything published in Macedonia was included in the database. The analytical studies firstly refer to the category.
Category
The category ofthe pottery defines the balance between practical and esthetical. The preponderance of the semi-fine ceramic defines practical communities. The dominance of the fine ceramic defines richness, welfare or workshops. A balance in favor of the common pottery suggests involution and decay. Following the extractions from the database and considering the information that we held, we have accomplished seriations, more precisely, analysis of clusters. 100% = саат ед Anzabegovo Па 90% + Ш H Rug Bair
HE Anzabegovo Ib BIn2 10% + Ш Anzabegovo Ш 60% -| BE Anzabegovo II-III 50% - Hi Anzabegovo Ib Вап3 40% + BAnzabegovo Ic 30% PeSterica
Ba Anzabegovo Ib fae П Anzabegovo Ia 10% Ш | O Porodin
Fig. 1. Chart of the pottery category from Macedonia10
Fine Semi-fine Rough
Figure | shows the percentual distribution of the pottery category coming from all the Neolithic sites in Macedonia. From the total, we have excluded those presenting a percentage smaller than 1%.11 It can be observed that the majority (35%) of the ceramic is of fine type. The semi-fine ceramic is represented in a smaller proportion (33%). From figure 1 we can notice that the great majority of the ceramic of fine type belongs to the phase Anzabegovo Ia, Ib, and Ic. The semi-fine ceramic is dominant in the Anzabegovo II phase but also among the materials from Porodin and PeSterica. The semi-fine type pottery is associated mostly with Anzabegovo II and is present among the materials from Porodin.
The rough type ceramic from Anzabegovo II and Porodin is overwhelmingly preponderant as compared to the other stations. This would mark a process of involution, interpreted by some as a migration from north towards south, an opinion that has not been sufficiently proved.12 Our belief is that this process deals with a natural evolution that took place in the entire area of the Balkans occurring at the end of the monochrome stages. The same situation happened in the intra-Carpathian region at Gura Baciului and Ocna Sibiului.13 In the chart regarding the pottery category from the Anzabegovo culture, the distribution of phases can be distinguished. The most numerous is the fine ceramic (Fig. 1) from Anzabegovo Ia.
These certify the presence of workshops considering the exceptional quality of the technologies and the painting. This species of pottery is followed by the semi-fine type. However, when compared to the prior percentages, there are no great changes because the types of ceramic from the Velu&ka-Porodin group have been represented by a smaller number of fragments (this being caused by the publishing style: short reports, the lack of monographs) as can be noticed in figure 1 (only 137 situations that count to the comparison). This is why we consider the comments upon the ceramic categories from the VeluSka-Porodin culture, in regards to this attribute, superfluous. M Madzari Ш
NERA: ew ky HOE f: Anzabegovo Ia B1n2 40% = БА ЧЕ = ©) Anzabegovo II-III 20% | 1 | БЕ Govrlevo I 0% + , . ; ph, T T T T T И MadzZari II
y Ш Anzabegovo Ia
EB MrSevci I
Fig. 2. Chart of the pottery color14 from Macedonia Color
The extraction from the database of the color of the pottery (although the published material is small: 594 fragments), especially outer color, shows that the largest number of pottery fragments comes from MrSevei I (11.3%), where the species D (orange) is dominant, followed by the color light brown (H), while at Anzabegovo I is the red ceramic (K) that occupies the first position followed by the dark brown (E).
These colors are predominant in the first two places in figure 2 with percentages equal to 19.7% from the total of the published materials for the Neolithic stations from Macedonia. From the chart regarding the pottery color from Macedonia, their distribution on sites (Fig. 2), and their descending arrangement can be noticed. Most of the fragments come from the stations of the group Anzabegovo-Vrsnik when compared to VeluSka-Porodin. Madzari III is at the bottom of the table with few materials: 1%. The species K=red (19.7%) together with H=light brown (19.7%) are specific for Macedonia being followed by
In the seriated table 1 we can observe that some of the stations appear to be early, but because the materials were not published on complexes it is difficult to speak in general. However, at the station MadZari, which was better excavated and published, we observe that the materials from house | are situated in the middle of the evolution. The table shows a series of early clusters (Govrlevo I, Dolno Paléi8te I), in general chronologically dated in Anzabegovo-Vrsnik la and Ib, Stenée 1, Madzari II house 1, MrSevci 1, Grgur Tumba (although with a few materials). In the late clusters from the series (marked with *) some materials from the level Anzabegovo Ia-Ib are gathered (probably a mixture caused by the large pits, not being published on complexes or levels from the pits but considering the depth, otherwise mentioned).15
This station, with all its attributes, has been declared as being part of the middle Neolithic. Anzabegovo Ia and Ib belong to the same phase, as the '*C data do not show great differentiations either. At MrSevci there are complexes from at least two stages. The materials from MrSevci show a development that occurs over several stages.
Mixture
We have extracted from the database the attributes concerning the mixture'® of the paste, based upon the dynamics of the materials resulting from researches or publishing. Unfortunately, there are no reports with statistical data about the stations, levels or complexes. We have not had access to study the materials from the deposits, as these do not have any working areas for the researchers. That is why our analysis is limited to what was published. We observe that the species S is dominant (pounded rock=30.7%), followed by the species 1 (sand=17.6%), 2 (fine sand=17.2%) and 3 (sand with big granulation=10.2%). These are a local characteristic of16 the workshops for the station Anzabegovo (Ia, Гр, Ic, II and III).
From figure 3 we observe that more than one third of the characteristic material comes from the level Anzabegovo la (38.5%), followed by Anzabegovo Ib. Furthermore, it can be noticed that at the end of the series, Anzabegovo Ia until Anzabegovo Ib are in the same cluster. However, M. GaraSanin in 1998 gave up on defining a stage monochrome ex-Anzabegovo Ia, synchronizing it with Pre-Sesklo.17
Anzabegovo Ia Gr. V
Anzabegovo Ia Gr. Il
E Anzabegovo Ia Gr. 12
Ш Anzabegovo Ia BIn2
Z PeSterica
O Anzabegovo II Fig. 3. Chart of the pottery
П Anzabegovo la mixture from Macedonia At the other end of the series is the station PeSterica and Trn I bonded by the mixture type 2 (fine sand) and E (sand and chaff), although in the older literature, PeSterica was considered as being the process of genesis, which is possible for that area but not for all of Macedonia. From the chart regarding the pottery mixture we can notice the arrangement of the stations on the basis of the percentages represented by the different patterns (Fig 3).
From the analysis of the table 2 it can be observed that the species 2 (sand) is a general characteristic of the mixture attribute. Therefore more stations with this attribute appear.
In the group Veluska-Porodin, the most numerous ceramics, with a 31.6% percentage, is the one containing sand and chaff (E=31.6%) (tab. 2) being a characteristic of the group.
The most frequent type at Anzabegovo-Vrsnik is the species 5 (pounded rocks) (tab. 2). It represents 33.3% from the total of the ceramic of this culture being followed by the species 2 (fine sand) and 3 (sand with big granulation).
Smoothness18
Analyzing the technique of surface treatment (smoothness) from figure 4 we observe that at Anzabegovo Ia (19.2%) and Ib (12.2%), the most numerous species is represented by the polished pottery (species 1), being however a characteristic for the mixture with minerals and fine sand. This species is around 52.9 % being also a general characteristic for Macedonia, which would justify the names of the groups Anzabegovo-Vrsnik or VeluSka-Porodin.
The species with slip (unsmoothed slip) is an early element, appearing in Transylvania at the level SC IC. The number of ceramic fragments is small (172 pieces), any further comment being useless. The seriation from table 3 includes almost all of the stations between Anzabegovo Ia and Ib, leading to the conclusion that smoothness is not a chronological but a cultural characteristic.
EB Lopate III 90 E) Mrsevei I 80 НП Anzabegovo Ib Bin2 60 +4 K Anzabegovo Ia B1n2 50 | Anzabegovo Ic
i Anzabegovo Ib BIn3
B Stenée Ш
H Anzabegovo II-III
E Porodin
П Anzabegovo Ib
13 33F4H567BG_ BAnzabegovo la Fig. 4. Chart of the pottery
MAnzabegovo II smoothness from Macedonia
Burning19 Like smoothness, burning"® also has a small number of materials (158 fragments, figure 5), the main stations being Anzabegovo Ia and Ib, with a total of 64%.
From the point of view of the species, we observe that the good oxidant burning (25.3%) occupies the first position, followed by good reductible and blackrand, and in a smaller & Vrsnik IV
45 © Lopate Ш
40 —] @ Porodin
30 4 § Anzabegovo Ia Binl
25 4 55 EJ Anzabegovo Ic
20 + Ц Zelenikovo 1
15 TE @ PeSterica
5 +H = Ш Anzabegovo III
6 Rug Bair o си oS we @ Anzabegovo II Fig. 5. Chart of pottery
Anzabegovo Ia burning from Macedonia
percentage blacktopped (figure 5). These also represent cultural series and not chronological ones.
From the seriation (tab 4) a gathering of later elements around Anzabegovo Ib, Anzabegovo Ia, па and II can be observed, denoting a local characteristic. Lopate III, Mogila I and Anzabegovo ГУ are not correlated.
Shapes20
Tables 5, 6 and 7 present the seriation of the pottery shapes*® from the Macedonian Neolithic
from all phases. Besides the archeological mixtures which disturb the series (depth based publication not on complexes), there are cultural series determined by local evolutions.
1990, T. III/1-5, 6/1-3, 6a/1-5, IV/1, IV/2/1-4; Aslanis I. 1992, fig. 10/1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 11; Gara’anin M. 1998a, p. 7, 33, fig. 3/a, c, 4; Zdravkovski D. 2004, sl. 15, 16, 21/1, 2, 22/1-4, 23/1-5, 32/1-4, 33/1-6, 35/4, 36/1, 50, 51/1, 52-56, 59/a-v, 60/1, 2, 61/1, 62/1- 7, 100d/1-7, 63/1-3, 64/2, 3, 65/1-5, 66/1-4, 67/1-4, 68/1-4, 69/1-4, 74/a-v, 75, 76/a, 77/1a, 2a, 77/3-6, 78/1, 2, 78, 79/1-3, 83/1, 2, 84/1, 85/1, 86/a, b, v, 90, 100Б/1-5, 100v/1-6, 101g, v, 103a, b, 110a, b, 121a/1, 2, 121b/1, 122b-f, 126a-d, 127a, Б, 128a/1, 2, 129a, b, 130, 138b/1, 140, 141a-c, 143a/1, 2, b/1, 2, 144a; Temelkoski D.-Mitkoski A. 2005, sl. la, b, 2a, b, 3a-f, T. I/1-17, пл- 10, III/1-12, IV/1-9, V/1-11, VI/1-10, VII/1-6, VIII/1, X/1-9, IX/1-14, XI/1-15, XII/1-7, XIII/ 1-14, XIV/1-8, XV/ 8, XVI/1, 5-8; Mitkoski A. 2005, T. Ill; Zdravkovski D. 2006, sl. 1-4, 15, 17-21, 50-52, 74. In tables 5 and 6 (seriated) the ceramic shapes of the stations from Anzabegovo-Vrsnik group are analyzed and in table 7 those for VeluSka-Porodin.
Table 5 shows that the earliest shapes are the legs type Xp21 which appear in Anzabegovo Ia, followed by globular pots. Furthermore, it can be noticed that the phase Anzabegovo Ia shows
a certain retardation of the development (confirmed by the American excavations of Marija Gimbutas team, via '*C datation related with SC IC,21 this due to multiple shapes from many levels dated with a general term of Anzabegovo Ib). The table shows a natural development of the phases and their hierarchy, starting with the cluster from the phase Anzabegovo Ib B1n3, continuing with Anzabegovo Ic, Dolno Paléiste 1, Mrsevci I ekc.
In table 6, which is a continuation of the preceding table, it can be noticed that the evolved Neolithic stations are Stenée I, Nemanjici, Kanli Cair and Anzabegovo Ib etc. However, the series would define a SC IC/Ila and would be associated with the development of the second migration. The earliest shapes that appear are the bowls and globular pots, followed by the cup leg and flat plates. These correspond to the evolution from Gura Bactului П (SC П).22
22 Lazarovici Gh.-Maxim 7. 1995, fig. 42-43.
If we look at the seriation from table 7, which contains the materials from the VeluSka-Porodin group, we notice that phase Veluska Tumba III as well as Topoléani IIB, but also materials from Vrbjanska Cuka, have retardations.
At Vrbjanska Cuka, materials from at least six stages can be observed. At Velu8ka Tumba Ш and Topoléani IIB there are mixed materials from preceding phases.
Ornaments
Painted ornaments
Following the seriation performed over the painted2223 Neolithic ceramic three tables have resulted, due to the large number of ornaments and the diversity of the painted material. Two of the tables (table 8 and 9) present the situation of the Neolithic stations from Anzabegovo-Vrsnik group, and the third table (tab. 10) presents the case of the Neolithic stations from the VeluSka-Porodin group. In table 8 it can be noticed that the clusters form a diagonal from right to left or starting from Dolno Pal¢iSte I towards Zelenikovo II.2.
These clusters present the situation of the painted motives on phases and, as can be noticed, some phases dated as earlier appear towards the end of the table showing that they are however associated with later phases. Here the phase Anzabegovo XII (upon Bregant’s chart ornaments) is among the earlier phases, represented by motives with the code HP and HN, but these are elements of retardation of the fourth phase from Anzabegovo. There are parallelisms with earlier evolutions between Čubuk Češma I and Anzabegovo Ic or Anzabegovo Ib B1n3.
In table 10 the seriations of the painted materials from the culture VeluSka-Porodin are presented. By analyzing the table, it can be seen that VeluSka Tumba occupies the beginning of the evolution; Porodin, Vrbjanska Cuka, Mogila Ш the middle of the evolution; then Grgur Tumba, Mogila I-II, have early elements.
The common element of this culture is the ornament painted with white with the codes LO, LOI, LO2 or as they are known in the literature under the name of “up-side down sigma”. This ornament, being common for many stations, also appears as a retardation in time, but we cannot consider it a retardation as long as the materials are not published on complexes, but only on stratigraphical levels.
Thus, this ornament can be a common one to some of the earlier stations, with some of the later ones, just for a certain period, sometimes being a local evolution.
From the seriation of the stations on phases in table 12 it can be observed that Anzabegovo Ib (as there are fewer ornaments at Anzabegovo Ia it has been considered monochrome, but was reevaluated, as shown before) once again appears on the first position.
This observation denotes the fact that once more the materials from Anzabegovo Ib are the earliest, not taking into consideration some mixtures of materials placed by the computer almost always in the center or at the other end of the series.
Table 12 represents a continuation of table 11. It can be observed that there is an evolution from left to right and that the materials from Anzabegovo Ia are grouped together with those from
the phase Anzabegovo Ic. This placement of the materials shows that in the phase Anzabegovo Ia materials from the phases that follow this one, have also been placed, monochrome being a theoretical separation, as we have already24 mentioned.
The materials seriated in table 13 present the situation of the Neolithic stations from VeluSka-Porodin group on phases. From the table it can be noticed that some of the stations like Mogila II, Topoléani IIB, Vrbjanska Cuka, Velu3ka Tumba II occupy the middle of the cultural evolution. This time at the site from Vrbjanska Cuka, materials from several stages of development can also be noticed. The sites from Zlastrana and PeSterica appear to be earlier but at PeSterica materials that would occupy a later phase of the early Neolithic appear. The site from Zlastrana has been declared a settlement with just one layer although the author25 did not exclude the possibility that earlier phases could exist, a fact that is also confirmed from our seriation. We propose the supposition that this site situated at the exit of the river Crn Drim from the lake Ohrid, has been a lacustrine settlement, although the researches could not confirm this. In the future our supposition might be confirmed and we hope that this could be one of the oldest settlements from the Balkan’s Neolith. 28 Grbi¢ M. & alii 1960, T. XY/1, 5, 6, XVI/S, XXII/3, XXXV/1, 5, 6, 8, 9; Bregant T. 1968, T. П/57, 84, 124, 125, 145; Korošec P.- Korošec J. 1973, p. 25, 29, 30, 33, 34, 44, 46, 49, 50, 53, 54, T. XVI/2, 15, XVIII/4, 5, 11, 14, XIX/3, 4, 21-23, 17, 18, 30, XXIII/1, 3, 5, 6, XXIV/2-5, 7-9, 11, 12, 14, XXV/1, 6-10, 12, XXVI/2-5, 8-13; Simoska D.-Sanev V. 1975, T. III/1, 24, IV/1-4; Gimbutas M. 1976, p. 29-37, fig. 33/1-3, 32/1, 43, 56; Mock R. 1976, p. 84, 85, 96, 111-114, fig. 47/1, 2; Kitanoski B. 1976, T. X/48-50; Kitanoski B. & alii 1978, p. 16/29; Simoska D. & alii 1979, p. 10/7, 12/8, 10, 11, 14, 17; Kitanoski B. & alii 1987, T. Ш/5-8; Kuzman P. 1990, T. VII, [X/9; Zdravkovski D. 2004, sl. 26/2, 5, 66/1-4, 68/3, 69/2, 74/a-y, 75, 87/b, 126a, 137/4, 146/1; Temelkoski D.-Mitkoski A. 2005, T. IV/5, VI/1, 4, 10, 11, VIII/1, X/5, XII/5, XIV/17, XV/1-3, 8; Mitkoski A. 2005, T. Ш.
From the seriated table 14 results that the earliest types of pottery with barbotine are associated with the phases Anzabegovo Ia and Ib. From the same table it can also be noticed that the barbotine appears the earliest for the Velu3ka-Porodin group, at Vrbjanska Сика.
Here at Vrbjanska Cuka, a development on several phases can also be observed, as shown in
table 14. The species of barbotine with the codes IA, IB, IC and IG present a certain retardation of the development, because they are not arranged in a diagonal from right to left which would have demonstrated a natural development of the stations.
Relative and Absolute Chronology
We are going to bring some contributions to the clarification of the absolute and relative chronology regarding the Macedonian Neolithic, based on the chronological connections that can be deduced correlating the data from the sites from Anzabegovo, the best published, with the rest of the Balkan regions and the Carpatho-Danubian regions. The radiocarbon data were taken mostly from the American researches.
We have chosen the Anzabegovo group or Anzabegovo-Vrsnik as a reference, because many researchers have focused their attention upon it, each trying to shed light on the issue of the chronology and the cultural and chronological connections.
Another issue is that of the synchronism between some elements belonging to the Neolithic cultures of the Macedonian territory, considering that these elements became common for several cultures in the Balkans, a fact that generated different opinions regarding the chronological and cultural placement of the Neolithic groups in Macedonia. Josip Korošec, as mentioned before, divided the discoveries27 from Anzabegovo in three phases correlating them with the Thessalian discoveries, at that time the study of Milojéi¢ V.28 not having yet been published.
Milutin GaraSanin divides the discoveries from Anzabegovo in four phases:
e The first phase with three subphases, Anzabegovo Ia-c:
a. Stage Ia is attributed at the beginning to the monochrome horizon, the others to the Protosesklo culture. The painting with white on a red background forming floral motives on large surfaces or a kind of “ribbon” and the “zig-zag” motives is attributed to the phases Anzabegovo Ia. The semiglobular pots, some with several short legs, belong to the same phase.
b. The next phase, Anzabegovo Ib, is represented by the ceramic painted with white, the motives
occupying the entire surface of the pot. The shapes belong to the semiglobular category.
Anzabegovo Ic has as motives, the painting with white, dots arranged continuously on a thin line forming garlands and floral motives on negative. The shapes of this phase are globular with
a flat bottom and a short or tall neck.
This phase, Anzabegovo I, with the three subphases is correlated by the author with the discoveries from the Staréevo I cultures, after the chronology elaborated by Draga GaraSanin”’.29
The phases Anzabegovo П and Anzabegovo III are related to Staréevo Џа-Пр. The fourth phase was associated with the end of30 the phase Startevo III and the beginning of the phase Vinéa I (Vinéa
M. GaraSanin later abandons the idea of the monochrome from Anzabegovo Ia, synchronizing it with Pre-sesklo,31 and regarding the phase Anzabegovo Ic he will mention correlation with the northern Danube area.32
The third opinion regarding the chronology of the Macedonian Neolithic is that of Marija Gimbutas who in her monograph on the excavation from the campaign 1969/70, divides the discoveries from Anzabegovo in three phases of development: Anzabegovo I with two subphases Anzabegovo II also with two subphases and Anzabegovo III. The fourth phase, Anzabegovo IV, is considered a later development of the late Neolithic.33
Following our analysis upon the pottery, we have considered the opinion of Gh. Lazarovici, which established four migrations, the most appropriate one because it appears to be more complete to address the issue of the chronology of the Macedonian Neolithic. Also, his method of approach is not declarative but deductive. He replaces the declarations regarding the evolution with the mathematical algorithm: the analysis of clusters or seriation, nuanced classifications and statistical interpretations which play a secondary role because the materials and the information are selective and were published selectively.
Gh. Lazarovici combined the chronological comparative system of Tatjana Bregant regarding the ornaments, based on the stratigraphy of Anzabegovo and the researches from Greece with the discoveries from the Danube region, accepting viable systems of chronology (Dimitrijevi¢) but having reserves and expressing criticism towards the stratigraphy and the interpretations from Donja Branjevina, thus creating a chronological system based on analytical archeology.34
For the chronology of the Neolithic stations from Macedonia, we have tried by gathering radiocarbon data (“C) to accomplish a system of chronological periodization. The majority of the '4C data were obtained from the official site of the seminar CANeW (Central Anatolian Neolithic e-Works)35 from the section about Anatolia and the Balkans, and also from the other publications.36 After reviewing several publications, we have gathered data about the Neolithic stations from the Balkans but unfortunately for Macedonia there are only data about the site Anzabegovo and two data about the site Vrsnik. The '*C data about the site from VrSnik cannot be used because they have a margin of error which is too large (150 years) compared to the modern radiocarbon data for which the biggest margin of error is 80 years and the smallest reaches 20 to 30 years. The '*C data obtained were processed using the software CalibS. for data calibration which can be acquired from the official site*’.37
Starcéevo-Cris la horizon 6200-6100 B.C.
Because the phenomena occur on large areas, we believe that the appropriate term would be horizon not phase. Gh. Lazarovici declared the Star’evo-Cris (SC) IA phase hypothetical because there are no closed complexes in the majority of the stations from the Carpatho-Danubian-Balkan region (maybe at Miercurea Sibiului**38 where B9 and B10 are closed complexes with predominantly monochrome pottery, see below the chronological and cultural links). Otherwise, also at Anzabegovo, there are no closed complexes with undisturbed material (in situ). The existence of this phase is proved by the fact that there are closed houses (pit houses and pits) with monochrome pottery obtained by burning not by applying different dyes (slip, angobe) to obtain uniform colors on the entire surface of the pot, as noticed in the case of the pit house B2A at Gura Baciului. These kinds of closed complexes or with this sort of pottery are rare (Gura Baciului, Miercurea Sibiului and with some reserves Miercurea Sibiului and Donja Branjevina).39 Phase Ia40 from Anzabegovo is hypothetical because the materials declared as Anzabegovo Ja“? after the mathematical-algorithmical-factorial analysis were proved to be contemporary with those of Staréevo-Cris IC.41 M. Gara8anin also reviewed his chronological placements,42 and Gh. Lazarovici analyzed the so called monochrome materials43 from Marija Gimbutas’ excavations and also had some reserves, proposing the existence of some early materials. This phase is the result of the first migration and the settlement of the first Neolithic communities in Macedonia as well as in the Danube region and the Carpathian arc.44
The data calibration shows that the phase Anzabegovo Ia belongs to the first migration, which after datation was somewhere between 6200 and 6100 B.C. (Fig. 7). Staréevo-Cris Ib horizon 6100-6000 B.C.
This horizon appears in many Neolithic stations from the Balkans as Anzabegovo from Macedonia, Kovatevo, Krajnici si Vaksevo from Bulgaria,45 Grivac 51 Donja Branjevina from Serbia, Carcea, Gradinile and Gura Baciului from Romania, but closed complexes could only be found in a few situations (only at Gura Baciului and Miercurea Sibiului). In this stage, the dynamism of the pottery technology, the ornamentation with white and the motives with dots, triangles arranged in a net pattern, parallel lines on a dark color background and also the pottery production (the red and brown angobe, and red slip appear more frequently), evolves and their correlation draws a line of migration
SC (a (6200-6100) Ib (6100 - 6000) Ic (6000-5900)
Sesklo Ill GHY-16843 nn a 1 Achilleion IIfb LJ-3327 — Galabnik Bln-3580 ——— = kaj sod Stara 7. Bok ¥ Bln-1587 сте 1 Gura Baciului GrN-24137
from the Vardar valley, Morava valley towards the Danube and Carpathian region.46 The “C data indicates a datation between 6100 and 6000 B. C for this Neolithic horizon (Fig. 7).
Starcevo-Cris Ic horizon 6000-5900 B.C.
This horizon is contemporary with some materials from Anzabegovo Ia as were declared by the excavations authors from Anzabegovo. The variety of the pottery painted with white is growing in opposition with the decline of the red pottery quality. The grooves and the gray pottery appear in this period. The SC Ic horizon is considered as one in which the second migration occurs from the South (Anatolia), causing changes in the quality of the pottery. However, the rest of the attributes and the shapes of the pottery are not different from the previous.47 In this phase, contemporary with Anzabegovo-VrSnik I, would be Grivac and Donja Branjevina from Serbia, Carcea-Hanuri I, Gradinile and Gura Baciului I (as named in the general terminology but with differences at Gh. Lazarovici) from Romania. The evolution of this stage is notable based on statistical and analytical differentiations, for each site and complex Until now, they beneficiate from a local cultural development,48 however, in the case of the migrations, a generalization at a large scale occurs.49 From our observations upon this horizon regarding the radiocarbon data we could establish that it was chronologically placed between the years 6000 and 5900 B.C. (Fig. 7).
Starcevo-Cris Ic/Ha horizon 5900-5850 B.C.
This horizon was vaguely defined because the second migration was noticed in different areas of the Balkans and the Danube regions. It is contemporary with the sites Proto-sesklo, Nea Nikomedeia and Magoulitsa from Greece and with Galabnik, Stara Zagora, Okrazna Bolnica IV from Bulgaria. Upon C" radiocarbon data it appears to be between 5900 and 5850 B.C. (Fig. 7). This horizon is associated with the second migration as mentioned before, which brings a new developing impulse from the South, but also a certain standardization. Now, colored motives with black or transparent black on white and red also begin to appear along with the white motives. This is also a horizon of local development at least for Macedonia, Bulgaria in Marica basin, or in Transylvania.50
Starcevo-Cris Па horizon 5850-5750 B.C.
In this horizon, the pottery of very good quality, the painting with black and red, the meander motives, narrow or wide lines, large of white areas (sometimes called solid stile), the white and the cream slip appear. Also, the ornament with pinches is generalized. All these elements lead to the conclusion of a migration coming from the South towards the North from Anzabegovo Па, with white floral motives from Macedonia, Podgorie from Albania towards Pavlovac, Teci¢ and Donja Branjevina from Serbia, Karanovo I and Vaksevo from Bulgaria, Gura Baciului II and Carcea II from Romania (Fig. 8). Furthermore, for these links the typology of the little shrines decorated with impressed triangles is suggestive.
Staréevo-Cris Пр horizon 5750-5700 B.C.
Here, we deal with a retardation stage (noticeable in the evolution of the pottery in some areas for instance at Gura Baciului) where all the elements of quality and ornamentation are put into practice. The ceramic continues to be of monochrome type with red dark gray or dark brown color. The surface is well polished. In the stations which are in a retardation process it appears (Lepenski SC Ila (5900-5750) Пр (5750-5700)
Servia ВМ-ТТОЗ CT 7 Theopetra (. DEM-455 =a Dudestii V. ȘCIIA GrN-28111 Stata 7. Bol IV Bln-1589 — | Miercurea Sib. B1 GrN-28521 Se Elesnica Blyp-3242 La] 4 Galebrik Blh 3582 a: Karanovo | Bln-4338 Eas eI
Vir, Gornea-Locurile Lungi). The red pottery appears as a follow-up to the use of slip or of the angobe. The yellowish pottery in stations that are in a developing process (pink buff - skin color) has painting with transparent colors and the mixture is sand-like. In this horizon the contemporary stations would be Anzabegovo IIb from Macedonia, Schela Cladovei, Gornea-Locurile Lungi, Parța-Tell 2, Gornea-Căunița de Sus, Pojejena I and Cuina Turcului II from România, Vršac At and Blagotin Ob. 03 from Serbia, Kova¢evo and Azmak 1/1 from Bulgaria®52 (Fig. 8).
Angeleski 5. 2005, p. 191-195.
SC Illa (5700-5650) Шар (5650-6600) ШБ (6600-5500)
Staréevo-Cris Ta horizon 5700-5650 B.C.
This horizon has been named the Girlandoid stage by Stojan Dimitrijevi¢ because of the panting with garlands that appears (dots arranged on both sides of a thin line) with dark colors.
In the Balkans, a different evolution happened for each region, and the notion of Girlandoid, in the opinion of Gh. Lazarovici, is valid only for the Danube region, being the result of new migrations, as at the same time the spreading of the neolitization in the East occured.
For this period, correspondences would Бе in the discoveries from Anzabegovo IIIa, Zelenikovo II, Pernik from Bulgaria, Zitkovac, Gladnica, Grabovac and Lepenski Vir from Serbia, Crvena Stijena and Zelena Peéina from Bosnia and Verbicioara I from Romania and others (see below). The ornaments with spirals, with dark colors from din Anzabegovo, Zelenikovo and Startevo brought with the new wave of migration give birth to the SC Ша horizon, the '‘C data indicating the period
“3 Lazarovici Gh. 2009 manuscript, opinions based on the newest publications of J. Makkay: Makkay J.-Starnini E, 2008. between 5700 and 5650 B.C. (Fig. 9). In this period, but especially after the second migration (from the previous stage), the wooden surface constructions begin.54
Staréevo-Cris ITa/1ITb 5650-5600 B.C. horizon
This horizon is different from one area to the other. As far as the attributes we mention: the pottery decorated with grooves and for the surface treatment technique, the yellowish, black and gray slip. In the South a well polished ceramic appears, sometimes with grooves and the blacktopped species. As specific shapes of pottery, there are cups (globular, tronconic, slight bi-tronconic, pots with a short clubbed leg), as specific ornaments, there is the barbotine with proeminences, and in the South various types of barbotine decoration occur. Also between the ornaments appear and develop the fine incisions. This horizon is better defined by the discoveries from Staréevo Pits ба, 4, 7, 19, Pavlovac-Gumniste, Srpski Krstur from Serbia and Dudesti Vechi, Liubcova®55 from Romania and others.
Staréevo-Cris IIIb horizon 5600-5500 B.C.
Now, the fourth migration is announced (previously considered the third). The characteristics of this horizon are the painted pottery and the polychromy (bichromy and trichromy), thick slip, the standardization of the mixture with crushed ceramic fragments. The fine type pottery with the colors gray, black and dirty yellowish, polished, organized or onamented barbotine, wide, deep, vertical, oblique or in a net incisions, wide incisions, fine incisions with motives in nets, triangles, rhombs, lines, on a brown sand-like pottery, sometimes black with spots containing a mineral mixture are predominant. The bitronconic shapes are represented by jars, bowls, cups, cups with tall clubbed leg. This horizon would be contemporary with the discoveries from Staréevo pit SA, 7, Krsti¢eva Humcea from Serbia, Pojejena II, Dudesti Vechi, Ostrovu Golu II, Gornea-Cdunifa de sus from Romania and many others. In general, this horizon is composed of elements almost common with those from Polichrome and SpiraloidA, but the technique of the pottery differs from that of Vinéa Al. This is the moment when the fourth migration occurs giving birth to the Balkan-Anatolian Chalcolithic, to the Vinéa culture but also to a series of local groups dependent on the intensity of the autochthon background, in Balkans and in the Danube region. The radiocarbon data placed this horizon between 5600 and 5500 B.C.56 (Fig. 9).
Staréevo-Cris [Va horizon 5000-5350 B.C.
In this horizon, contacts have been made between the phases Vinéa A2 and Dimitrijevi¢’s Spiraloid B contemporary with the phase Vinéa A2, with bilateral imports. Now, some pottery species have mineral mixture, blacktopped burning or with spots, the shapes are bitronconic and among the ornaments there are fine polished or incised lines on a black or brown surface, the mixture of the paste is sandy and the semifine and rough species have crushed ceramic fragments in the paste composition. Among the ornaments, there are sprayed as well as organized barbotine, alveolar or non-alveolar belts, spirals, ““wasp’s nest” or ““comb”, rosettes, the white or black painting on a white or gray background. The thick, white, red, brown and many time mixed with mineral type of slip again appears.
This horizon has been the product of a migration and diffusion between the middle Polichrome (with spirals in Oltenia area from Romnia and at South at GradeSnica C in Bulgaria) and the B Spiraloid (for the groups from Vojvodina, Backa, Srem). The most significant sites where it can be found were Karanovo II, GradeSnica C in Bulgaria, Carcea, Trestiana, Gornea and Ostrovu Golu din Romania, Pavlovac Čukar, Crnokalačka Bara from Serbia (Fig. 10).57 Staréevo-Cris IVa/IVb horizon 5350-5300 B.C.
Now, the ethno-cultural process on large areas enter in retardation. This phase is better known in Macedonia, where the phenomenon continues its development, especially at Anzabegovo.58 Materials can also be found at VrSac in Serbia and Foieni-Sd/as in Romania.59
Staréevo-Cris IVb horizon 5300-5250 B.C.
This phase is the last one of the Staréevo culture. It is known in just a few stations. Some of these are Anzabegovo IVb from Macedonia, Ostrovu Golu IV, Gornea, Iclod, Gura Baciului IV from Romania.
Now only conglomeration of materials appear, the simple jars, the pots with rounded bottoms, tronconical, pointed bottom pots being predominant while the decorations have incisions, wide incisions, alveols, barbotine, belts and applied rosettes.60
Reviewing all the above, we have accomplished a table of comparative and absolute chronology . (Fig. 11), including the Neolithic stations from Маседопта.61 We have considered these62 two systems (T. Bregant 1968, Gh. Lazarovici 1995) (Fig. 11) as being more appropriate for Macedonia because of the method of approach of the excavation on layers. The reference for the codes used in the text, can be found in the catalogues presented in our PhD theses.
The comparative stratigraphy, in the above seriations, sometimes eliminated the notion of phase, because these are only declarative, in relation to the “archaeological school”. From the descriptions regarding the attributes, the limitations of the stratigraphical declarations and especially the lack of published material can be observed. But any new discovery, any new publication of materials makes the series more precise and thus the errors become fewer.
Sote Angeleski
Str. Parang. Nr. 11, ap. 103 400552 Cluj — Napoca, Romania s_angeleski@yahoo.com
СОТЕ АНГЕЛЕСКИ
Романија
АНАЛИТИЧКИ ОСВРТ ВРЗ МАКЕДОНСКИОТ НЕОЛИТ
Белешки
- GaraSanin M. [1969-70] 1998a. ↩
- Gimbutas M. 1976. ↩
- Korošec J. 1953; Korošec P.-Korošec J. 1973, p. 62; Bregant T. 1968. ↩
- GaraSanin M.-GaraSanin D. 1959, p. 61-65; GaraSanin M.-GaraSanin D. 1961, p. 7-45. ↩
- Srejovié D. 1965; Dimitrijevi¢ 5. 1969; Srejovi¢ D. 1971; Dimitrijevi¢ 5. 1974; Dimitrijevi¢ 5. 1978; Dimitrijevic 5. 7 Garašanin M. 1998; Tasić N. N. 1998; Tasić N. N. 1998a. ↩
- Gimbutas M. 1976, p. 30-31, 111-115. ↩
- Lazarovici Gh, 2000; Lazarovici C. M.-Lazarovici Gh. 2000. ↩
- Grbić M. & alii 1960, T. XIII/ 1-6, XV/1-6, XVI/1-5, XVII/1-5, XX/1-6, XXII/1-9, XXIII/1-7, XXIV/1, 2, XXXV/1-10, XXXVI/1-6, XXXVII/1-4, XXXVIII/4, 5, XLI/1-10, XLII/1, 2; Korošec P.- Korošec J. 1973, p. 22, 25, 26, 29, 30, 33-36, 40, 44, 47-51, 53, 54, 58, T. XV/1-4, XVI/1-4, 15, 19, XVII/2, 4, 7, 11, 14, XVIII/2, 3, 6, 7, 9, 10, 14, 16, 17, 23, 26; XIX/1-3, 5, 16, 19, 20, 22, 25, 26, 33, 35-38, 40; XX/1-26; XXI/1-18, 20-22, 24-26; XXII/1-10, 12, 14-17; XXIII/3, 5-7, 11-15; XXIV/3, 4, 7-9, 11, 14-17; XXV/I, 8-12; XXVI/S, 8, 9, 11-13; Gimbutas M. 1976, p. 29-37, 39-46, 48, 49, 50, 51, 53, 54-57, 60, fig. 14/1- 4, 15/1-3, 16/1-3, 17/1-3, 18/1, 2A, B, 19/1-4, 20/1-4, 21/1-4, 22/4-6, 23/1, 26/1, 2, 4, 27/2, 28/1-5, 30/1, 2, 4, 31/1-3, 7, 32/2- 6, 33/2, 34/1-2, 37/1, 2, 38/2, 39/1-3: Mock R. 1976, p. 79-88, 91, 95-98, 100-106, 111-116, fig. 43/1-3, 44/1-3, 45/1-2, 46/1- 3, 47/1-2, 48/2, 3, 5, 6, 49/ 1-10, 50/1-8, 57/1-3, 58/ 1-9, 59/1-8; Kitanoski B. 1976, T. VI/2-8, VII/9-15, VIII/16-24, LX/26, 27, 29-31, 34, X/48, 49, 50, 53, 54, 56-60, 63; X1/61, 62; GaraSanin M. 1979, T. XV/6, GaraSanin M. 1998a, p. 7, 32, 33, fig. 2/ae, 3/a-e, 4/a-c, 5/a, c-e. ↩
- From all the tables regarding the percentages, in the rest of the study, we have eliminated all the attributes that presented values below 1% because they represented their own equivalent. ↩
- Рахак J. 1991. ↩
- Lazarovici Gh.-Maxim 7. 1995, p. 74, 121; Luca S. A. & alii 2004. ↩
- Grbić M. & alii 1960, T. XIII/1, XIV/5, XX/5, 6, XXXVI, XXXVII, XLI/5, 7, 8, 9, 10, XLI/1-4, 6, XLII/1, 2; Galović R. 1967, p. 138-139; GaraSanin M. 1968, p. 154; Brukner B. 1968, p. 90-91; KoroSec P.- KoroSec J. 1973, p. 26, 29, 30, 32-37, 40, 43-54, 58, T. XV/1-4, 8, XVI/1-3, 5, XVII/1, 4, 7, 11, XVII/6-7, 14, 16, 17, XIX/1-7, 10, 15, 17, 19, 20-28, XX/2-4, 6-11, ↩
- , 15, 22, 23, 25, XXI/1, 4, 9, 12, 15, 18-20, 23-26, XXII/1, 2, 4, 5, 7-12, 14-16, XXIII/3, 5-7, 9-14, 15, XXIV/14, XXV/7, 9; Garašanin M. 1975, p. 10; 1979, pl. 9/2; Gimbutas M. 1976, p. 29-37, 42, 43, 48-51, 54, 57, fig. 14/1-3, 15/3, 16/1-3, 17/1- 3, 18/2A, B, 19/1-4, 22/5-6, 23/1, 26/1-4, 27/1, 28/1-3, 34/1-2; Mock R. 1976, p. 79-96, 111-114, fig. 43/1-3, 44/1-3, 45/1-2, 46/1-3, 47/1-2, 48/2-5, 49/1-10, 50/1-6; GaraSanin M.-Spasoyska G. 1976, p. 106-107; Kitanoski B. 1976, p. 163; Sanev2 V. & alii 1976, p. 13; Kitanoski B. 1977, p. 29, 34; Simoska D. & alii 1979, p. 21; Kitanoski B. & alii 1980, p. 10; GaraSanin M. 1989, p. 27-28; GaraSanin D. 1989, p. 41; Aslanis 1. 1992, pl. 10/3, 11; Sanev Y. 1994, p. 31; Korkuti M. 1995, pl. XI-XV, fig. 6-15; GaraSanin M. 1998a, p. 8, 12: 13; Zdravkovski D. 2004, sl. 17, 20/1-4, 25/1, 2, 27/1-7, 28/1, 2, 29/1-6, 30/1-7, 31/1-10, 51/1, 2, 55, 59/a-g, 60/1, 3-7, 62/2, 3, 5-7, 63/1, 3, 64/2-4, 65/1-5, 66/1-3, 67/1-3, 67/2, 68/3, 4, 69/2, 3, 74/a, b, g, v, 75, 76/a, b, 77/2a, 3, 4, 6, 77/la, 4, 78/2, 81/2, 83/1-3, 84/1, 85/1, 2, 86/a, b, y, 87/a, 88a/8, b/1-11, 90, 100 b/1-4, g/3, 4, v/2, 3, 6, 82/1- 3, 100g/1, 2, 5, 6, 100d/1-7, 100v/1, 4, 5, 100b, 101b, 101g, 101v, 102v, 103a, b, 110a, b, 120a, b, 121a/1, 2, 122/b-f, 126a-d, 127a, b, 128a/1, 2, 129a, 132a/1-4, Б/1, 2, e/1-4, d/1-4, 131a/1-4, Б/1-4, 133/1-4, 134/1, 2, 135 a/1, 2, Б/1, 2, 4, e/2- 4, 136a/1- 4, b/1-4, 137/1-7, 138/a, b/1, 2, c, 139/1, 2, 140, 141b, c, 142b/1-4, 141a, 142a/1-4, 143a/1, 2, b/1, 2, 144a, b, c, 145a, b, 146/1, 2; Zdravkovski D. 2006, sl. 1-4, 6-15, 17-21, 43, 50, 51, 52, 69, 72, 74. ↩
- (orange) and E (dark brown), colors that are characteristic for stage SC IC. ↩
- Lazarovici Gh. 2006, p. 145, tables 16a-16c. ↩
- Grbić M. 1967, p. 136-138; Garašanin M. 1968, p. 151; Korošec P.- Korošec J. 1973, p. 22, 30, 33-37, 40, 44, 49-51, 53, 54, 58, T. XV/1-4, XVII/4, 7, 11, 14, XVIII/6, 7, 9, 14, 16, 17, XIX/16, XX/1-12, 15, 19, 23, XXI/4, 9, 18, 20, 26; XXII/2, 4, 5, 7-12, 14-16, XXIII/3, 5, 6, XXIV/3, 9, 14, 17, XXV/7-9; Gimbutas M. 1976, p. 29-44, 46, 48, 49, 50, 57, 61, fig. 14/1-4, 15/1- 3, 16/1-3, 17/1-3, 18/2A, B, 19/1-4, 22/1-6, 23/1, 26/1-4, 27/1, 2, 34/1-2, 39/1-3; Mock R. 1976, p. 79-81, 84-88, 91, 100, 111- 113, 115-116, fig. 43/1, 2, 45/1-3, 46/1-3, 48/2-5, 49/1-2, 5-8; GaraSanin M.- Spasovska G. 1976, p. 10; Simoska D.-Sanev V. 1977, p. 225, 227-230; Kitanoski B. & alii 1980, p. 10, 12; Sanev V.-Stamenova M. 1989, p. 17; GaraSanin M. 1998a, p. 7, 8, 20, 32, fig. 2/a-c, 3/a-e, 4/a-c, 5/a-e. ↩
- Lazarovici Gh. 2006, p. 120-125. ↩
- Grbié M. & alii 1960, T. XLI/1-10, XLII/1, 2; Коговес P.- KoroSec J. 1973, p. 25, 26, 29-37, 40, 43, 44, 46, 49-51, 53, 54, T. XV/1, 3-5, 10, XVI/1, XVII/4, 7, 11, 14, XVIII/6, 7, 14, 16, 17, XIX/4, 5, 16, 22, 25, XX/2-4, 6-10, 11, 13, 22, 23, 25, 26, XXI/1, 9, 12, 15, 18-20, 23, 25, 26, XXII/1, 2, 5, 4, 7-12, 14-16, XXIII/3, 5, 6, 9-15, XXIV/3, 8, 9, 14, XXV/9, 12, XXVI/7, 12; Gimbutas M. 1976, p. 29-43, 46, 57, fig. 14/1-4, 15/1-3, 16/ 1-3, 17/1-3, 18/1, 2A, B, 19/1-4, 22/1-6, 23/1, 27/1, 2, 34/1-2: Mock R, 1976, p. 79-89, 91, 111-114, fig. 43/1-3, 44/1-3, 45/1-3, 46/1-3, 47/1-2, 48/1-5, 6, 49/ 2-6, 10; Zdravkovski D. 2004, sl. 90, 1004/1-7, 135e/1-4, 138a, 145a, b, Zdravkovski D. 2006, sl. 8-10. ↩
- Grbić M. & alii 1960, T. XIII/1, XIV/5; Galović R. 1964, p. 21, 26, 27; Korošcc P.- Korošcc J. 1973, p. 22, 34, 30, 33- 36, 40, 44, 53, 47, 49-51, 53, 54, 58, T. XV/1, 3, 4, XVI/1-3, XVII/4, 7, 11, 14, XVII/6, 7, 9, 14, 16, 17, XIX/9, 16, XX/2- 4, 6-10, 13, 22, 25, 26, XXI/1, 12, 15, 18-20, 23, XXII/1, 2, 4, 5, 7-12, 14-16, XXIII/3, 5, 10, 11, 13, 14, XXIV/3, 5, 8, 9, 14, 17, XXV/7-10, XXVI/5, XXVIII/6; GaraSanin M. 1975, p. 12; Gimbutas M. 1976, p. 29-38, 40-43, 44, 46, 50, 57, fig. 14/1-4, 15/1-3, 16/1-3, 17/1-3, 18/1, 2A, B, 19/1-4, 20/1-4, 21/1-4, 22/1-6: 26/1-4, 27/1, 34/1-2: Mock B. 1976, p. 78, 79, 82-88, 91. 100, 111-114, fig. 45/1-3, 46/1-3, 47/1, 2, 48/1-6, 49/2-3, 6-9; Simoska D. & alii 1979, p. 23; Zdravkovski D. 2004, sl. 139/1, 2. ↩
- Galović R. 1957, T. VII/2-3, 26-27; 1964, 20, 21, 26, 27; Garašanin D. 1959, p. 11; Garašanin M. 1959, T. IX/4, XV/5; Grbić M. & alii 1960, T. XIII/1-5, XIV/2, 5, XV/2, XVIII/1-7, XIX/1-10, XX/1-6, XXII/1-9, XXIII/1-6, XXIV/1, 2, XXXVI/1-7, XXXVII/1-4, XXXVIII/4, 5, XLII/1, 2; Brukner B. 1968, p. 60; Korošec P.- Korošec J. 1973, p. 29, 30, 34, 35, 40, 44, 47, 49-51, 53, 54, T. XV/1-3, XVI/1, 3, XVIII/10, 23, 26, XIX/3, 19, 26, 38, XX/1-10, 12-26, 33, 36, 37, XXI/1-12, 15-21, 23, 26, XXII/2-15, XXIII/7, 10, 13, 14, XXIV/3-5, 8, 9, 14, 15, XXV/1, 3, 7, 8, 9, XXVI/4, 11, 13; Simoska D.-Sanev V. 1975, T. IV/13, V/5, VI/1-6, VII/1-4, VIII/1-4, IX/1-3, X/2, X/1, XIII/1, 2, XIV/1, 2, XVI/1, 3, 4, 5, XVII/1-4; Gimbutas M. 1976, p. 29-45, 48-51, 53, 56, 57, 60, fig. 14/1-4, 15/1-3, 16/1-3, 17/1-3, 18/1, 2A, B, 19/1-4, 20/1-4, 21/1-4, 23/1, 26/1-4, 27/1, 2, 28/1-5, 30/1-4, 32/2, 33/1, 3, 34/1, 2, 37/1, 2, 38/1, 2, 39/1-3; Mock R. 1976, p. 78-91, 97, 111-116, fig. 45/1-3, 46/1-3, 48/3, 6, 49/1, 3, 5, 59/8; Kitanoski B. 1976, T. VI/2-6, VII/9-15, VIII/16-24, IX/26, 27, 30, 31, 34, XI/56; Kitanoski B. 1977, p. 31/1-10, 32/11-20, 35/22, 23, 26; Lazarovici Gh. 1977a, pl. 36, 37; Kitanoski B. & alii 1978, p. 12/1-10, 14/11-17, 16/22-29, 18/30-32, 35-40, 20/41-47, 22/49-56, 24/60-66, 26/68-73; Simoska D. & alii 1979, p. 10/1-6, 12/10, 11, 14/12, 13, 15/18-23, 16/24-27, 29, 30, 18/28, 31, 32, 34, 37, 19/38, 23-25, 22/56, 23, 24/67, 26/71; Garašanin M. 1979, T. IX/2, XV/1; Kitanoski B. & alii 1987, T. IV/1-5, V/1-5, VI/1-5, VII/1; Kuzman P. 1990, T. III/1-5, 6/1-3, 6a/1-5, IV/1, IV/2/1-4; Aslanis I. 1992, fig. 10/1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 11; Garašanin M. 1998a, p. 7, 33, fig. 3/a, c, d; Zdravkovski D. 2004, sl. 15, 16, 21/1, 2, 22/1-4, 23/1-5, 32/1-4, 33/1-6, 35/4, 36/1, 50, 51/1, 52-56, 59/a-v, 60/1, 2, 61/1, 62/1-7, 100d/1-7, 63/1-3, 64/2, 3, 65/1-5, 66/1-4, 67/1-4, 68/1-4, 69/1-4, 74/a-v, 75, 76/a, 77/1a, 2a, 77/3-6, 78/1, 2, 78, 79/1-3, 83/1, 2, 84/1, 85/1, 86/a, b, v, 90, 100b/1-5, 100v/1-6, 101g, v, 103a, b, 110a, b, 121a/1, 2, 121b/1, 122b-f, 126a-d, 127a, b, 128a/1, 2, 129a, b, 130, 138b/1, 140, 141a-c, 143a/1, 2, b/1, 2, 144a; Temelkoski D.-Mitkoski A. 2005, sl. 1a, b, 2a, b, 3a-f, T. I/1-17, II/1-10, III/1-12, IV/1-9, V/1-11, VI/1-10, VII/1-6, VIII/1, X/1-9, IX/1-14, XI/1-15, XII/1-7, XIII/ 1-14, XIV/1-8, XV/ 8, XVI/1, 5-8; Mitkoski A. 2005, T. III; Zdravkovski D. 2006, sl. 1-4, 15, 17-21, 50-52, 74. /56, 23, 24/67, 26/71; GaraSanin M. 1979, T. IX/2, XV/1; Kitanoski B. & alii 1987, T. IV/1-5, V/1-5, VI/1-5, пл; Kuzman P. ↩
- Lazarovici Gh. 2006, p. 143, fig. 36. ↩
- Lazarovici Gh.-Maxim Z. 1995, fig. 42-43. ↩
- От M. & alii 1960, T. XLI/2, 4, 6, 7, XLII/1, 2; Galovié R. 1968, fig. 3/2, 4/1, 4, 5, 5/2, 3, 5, 6/6, 7/3, 7, 9/1; Bregant T. 1968, Т. П/7, 13, 14, 17, 27-30, 32, 53-56, 83, 103, 106, 122, 123, 146-149, 175, 176, 178, 179, 183-186, 188, 189, 192-197, 200-202; Garaganin M. 1968, p. 157; GaraSanin M. 1975, p. 10; GaraSanin M.1979, p. 91, 92, T. XIII/1, 4, 6; Tasi¢ N.-Tomié E. 1969, 27, fig. 16.1, 79; Korošec P.- Korošec J. 1973, p. 26, 29, 30, 44, 46-48, 54, T. XVII/3, XIX/1, 2, 5-8, 10, 15, 16, 19, 20, 24-29, 31, 32, 34-37, 40, 41, XXI/7, 13, 22, 25, XXIII/7-11, 13-15, XXV/3, 4; Dimitrijevi¢ 5. 1974, p. 61; Simoska D.- Sanev V. 1975, p. 71, 72, 77, T. IX/3-5, X/1-5, XVII/3, 4, XVIII/1-8, XIX/1-6, 8-12; Sanev V. 1976, p. 14-15; Sanev V. & alii 1976, p. 13, 14; Kitanoski B. 1976, pl. X/52; Gimbutas M. 1976, p. 29-37, 43, 48; Mock R. 1976, p. 86, 87, 89, 90-92, 100- 102, 111-114, 116, fig. 48/1-6, 49/1-10, 50/1-8, 57/1-9, 59/1-8; Kitanoski B. 1977, p. 29, 36-34; Kitanoski B. & alii 1978, p. 12/3, 14/11; Simoska D. & alii 1979, p. 10/3, 11, 13, 18, 33-36, 22/58, 59, 62; GaraSanin M. 1979, T. XIII/1, 4, XV/1, 2, 6; GaraSanin D. 1989, p. 41, 42; Zdravkovski D. 1993, p. 21; Aslanis I. 1992, pl. 10/3; Sanev V. 1994, p. 30-32; GaraSanin M. 1998a, p. 7, 13, 33, fig. 3/a-e, 4/a-c, 5/a, c-e; Zdravkovski D. 2004, sl. 15-16, 17/1-6, 18/1-6, 19/1-6, 20/1-4, 29/1-7, 27/1-7, 28/1-2, 30/1-7, 31/1-10, 50, 51/1, 2, 52-55, 60/1-4, 79/2, 61/5-7, 72, 81/1-2, 82/1-3, 83/1, 3, 88a/8, b/2-11, 119a, b, 130, 131a/1- 3, b/1-4, 132a/1-3, b/1-4, e/1-4, d/1-4, 133/1-4: Temelkoski D.-Mitkoski A. 2005, T. П/7-8, XIII/ 1-7; Mitkoski A. 2005, T. III; Zdravkoyski D. 2006, sl. 1-14, 69. ↩
- Grbić M. & alii 1960, T. XV/2-4, XVII/3, XXII/2-5; Garašanin M.-Garašanin D. 1961, p. 40, 43; Galović R. 1964, p. 27-28; Bregant T. 1968, T. 1/18, 19, 61, 104, 105, 124, 125, П/145, 177, 187, 190, 191, 198, 199; KoroSec P.- Коговес J. 1973, p. 25, 29, 30, 33, 34, 36, 46, 47, 49-50, 53, 58, T. XV/1, 2, 4, XVI/4, 10-15, XVII/4, 5, 8-21, XVII/1-7, 11, 12, 14, 16-18, 21, 25, XTX/3, 11- 14, 21-23, 30, 38, XXI/6, 24, XXI/I1, XXIII/1-3, 5, XXIV/I1, 14, XXV/2, 5, 6, 10, XXVI/1; Simoska D.-Sanev Y. 1975, T. Ш2, V/1-5:; Kitanoski B. 1976, T. VI/2-4, VII/10, VIL/18, VIII/20, [X/29, X/51, 53, 55, XI/56-60; Gimbutas M. 1976, p. 29-37, 41, 43, 46, 54, 61, fig. 17/3, 22/1-6, 23/1, 31/1, 2, 39/1-3; Mock R. 1976, p. 82, 91, 95, 96, 111-116, fig. 47/1, 2, 50/8; Simoska D.-Sanev V. 1977, Ш1/За-4, 4-7, ГУ/3, 8-11, 15-17; Kitanoski B. & alii 1978, p. 14/14, 16, 16/29, 18/35, 36, 20/43, 45, 48, 24/64, 26/70, 36/30- 32; Simoska D. & alii 1979, p. 10/5, 12/8, 22/56, 60, 62; Kuzman P. 1990, T. VI, VII, ГХ/1-11: GaraSanin M. 1998a, p. 7, 32, fig. 2/a-e; Korkuti M. 1995, fig. 27/1-5, 32/13, 33/2-10, 34/1, 3, 5, 7, 8; Zdravkovski D. 2004, sl. 26/1-5, 65/1-5, 66/1-4, 67/2, 4, 68/1, 3, 69/1, 2, 74/a-v, 75, 76/b, 78/1, 86/b, v, 87/a-b, 100d/1, 2, 102v, 103a, 110a, b, 126a, 134/1, 2, 135a/1, 2. b/1, 2, 137/1-4, 138c, 146/1; Temelkoski D.-Mitkoski A. 2005, T. VIV/S, XIIV/10, 11, XTV/15, 19; Mitkoski A. 2005, T. III; Zdravkovski D. 2006, 51. 74 ↩
- Kuzman P. 1990, ↩
- Angeleski S. 2005, p 186. ↩
- Milojčić V. 1949; Milojčić von Zumbusch J.-Milojčić V. 1971. ↩
- Arandjelović-Garašanin D. 1954; Garašanin M. 1962; Garašanin M. 1968; Garašanin M. 1973; Garašanin M. 1975; Garašanin M.-Spasovska G. 1976; Garašanin M. 1979; Garašanin M. 1989; Benac A. 1989. ↩
- Grbić M. & alii. 1960; Garašanin M.-Garašanin D. 1959; Garašanin M.-Garašanin D. 1961; Garašanin M. 1968; Garašanin D. 1970; Garašanin M. 1979; Garašanin D. 1980; Georgiev Z.-Bilbija M. 1984; Garašanin M.-Bilbija M. 1984; Zdravkovski D. 1988; Garašanin D. 1989; Garašanin M. 1989; Zdravkovski D. 1989; Zdravkovski D. 1990; Zdravkovski D. 1993; Zdravkovski D. 1995; Bogdanović M. 1998; Vetnić 1998. ↩
- Garašanin M. 1998. ↩
- Garašanin M. 1997; Garašanin M. 1998, p. 8, 14-15, 18-19, 26-27; Garašanin M. 1998a; Temelkoski D. -Mitkoski A. 2001; Zdravkovski D. 2004; Zdravkovski D. 2006; Angeleski S. 2005, p. 186-187. ↩
- Gimbutas M. 1976; Angeleski 5. 2005, p. 187-188. ↩
- Bregant T. 1968; Lazarovici Gh.-Maxim 1995; Angeleski 2005, p. 188-190; Lazarovici Gh. 2006, p. 129; Lazarovici C. M.-Lazarovici Gh. 2006, p. 53-54. ↩
- http://www.canew.org ↩
- Gimbutas M. 1976; Greenfield H. J. - Drasovean E. 1994; Bonsall C. & alii 2000; Bartosiewicz L. & alii 2001; Biagi P. - Spataro M. 2004; Biagi P. 2005; Lazarovici Gh. 2006; Lazarovici C. M.-Lazarovici Gh. 2006; Lazarovici C. M.-Lazarovici Gh. 2007. ↩
- http://calib.qub.ac.uk/calib ↩
- Luca S. A. & alii 1998; Luca S. A. & alii 2004; Luca S. A. & alii 2005. ↩
- Lazarovici Gh. 2006, p. 131-132: Lazarovici C. M.-Lazarovici Gh. 2006, p. 60-65. ↩
- Gimbutas M. 1976. ↩
- Lazarovici Gh.-Maxim 7. 1995; Angeleski 5. 2005, 191-197; Lazarovici Gh. 2006, p. 129; Lazarovici C. M.-Lazarovici Gh. 2006, p. 53-54. ↩
- M. Garašanin 1998. ↩
- Lazarovici Gh. 2006, p. 9-12, 19, 36, fig. 3, 6a, 6b. ↩
- Lazarovici C. M.-Lazarovici Gh. 2006, p. 53-54; Lazarovici Gh. 2006, p. 131. ↩
- Lazarovici Gh. 1998a and the cited bibliography in the text, the tables and annexes on different kinds of attributes. ↩
- Lazarovici Gh.-Maxim 7. 1995, p. 5, 69, 78; Maxim 1999, p. 33-40; Lazarovici Gh. 2006, p. 133-138; Lazarovici C. M.- Lazarovici Gh. 2006, p. 56. ↩
- Lazarovici Gh. 2006, p. 138-144, Lazarovici C. M.-Lazarovici Gh. 2006, p. 56-57. ↩
- Lazarovici Gh. 1995, p. 5, 69, 78; Lazarovici Gh. 2006, p. 138-144, Lazarovici C. M.-Lazarovici Gh. 2006, p. 56-57. ↩
- Lazarovici Gh. 1996; Lazarovici Gh. 1998; Lazarovici Gh. 2006, p. 122-123. ↩
- Ibidem. ↩
- Lazarovici C. M.-Lazarovici Gh. 2006, p. 55. ↩
- Lazarovici C. M.-Lazarovici Gh. 2006, p. 55, 57. ↩
- Idem, p. 56-58; Luca S. A. 1985; Luca S. A. 1987a; Luca S. A. 1991a. ↩
- Lazarovici C.-M. & Gh. 2006, p. 57, 58. ↩
- Lazarovici Gh. 1977, p. 5-33; Lazarovici Gh. 1979, p. 3-40; Lazarovici Gh. 1984: Lazarovici Gh.-Maxim 7. 1995, p. 65- 92; Lazarovici Gh. 1998a, p. 20-24; Lazarovici C. M.-Lazarovici Gh. 2006, p. 58. ↩
- Bregant T. 1968. ↩
- Lazarovici Gh. 1977, p. 5-33: Lazarovici Gh. 1979, p. 3-40: Lazarovici Gh.-Maxim 7. 1995, p. 65-92; Lazarovici Gh. 1998a, p. 20-24; Maxim Z. 1999, p. 49; Lazarovici C. M.-Lazarovici Gh. 2006, p. 59. ↩
- e Lazarovici Gh. 1965; Lazarovici Gh. 1975; Lazarovici Gh. 1977; Lazarovici Gh. 1979, p. 77-79; Luca 5. A. 1987; Lazarovici Gh. 1987/88, p. 17-19, 21-25: Drasovean E. 1989; Lazarovici Gh. 1993, p. 12, 23-28: Drasovean E. 1993; Lazarovici Gh.-Maxim 7. 1995, p. 79, 93; Luca 5. A. 1995; Lazarovici Gh. 1998a, p. 24, 25: Luca 5. A. & alii 1998; Maxim 1999, p. 49: Luca 5. A. & alii 2004; Lazarovici Gh. 2004; Lazarovici Gh. 2005. ↩
- Angeleski 5. 2005, p. 183-204, Tab. 1, Fig. 2. ↩
- Angeleski 2009. AB Analele Banatului, Timisoara CPM Civilizacii na Poévata na Makedonija, Skopje Al Archaeologia lugoslavica, Belgrad DP Documenta Praehistorica, Ljubljana ↩
- Arheoloska karta na Makedonija, Skopje GINI Glasnik na Institutot4 za Nacionalna Istorija, AMN Acta Musei Napocensis, Cluj shone ↩
- Maced. acta Archeol. Macedoniae Acta Archaeologica, Anatolica Anatolica, Istambul Prilep/Skopje ↩
- Atlas du Néolithique Européen ERAUL, Liége MH Macedonian Heritage, Skopje ↩
- AnlCSUS Anuarul7 Institutului de Cercetari Socio-Umane, ; : ; a a ↩
- Sibiu PB Patrimonium Banaticum, Timisoara ↩
- Arheoloski Pregled, Beograd PIZ Praistorija Jugoslavenskih Zemalja, Sarajevo ATS Ayes Туна бината; Siti PZ Prehistorische Zeitschrift, Berlin - Leipzig AV Arhéoloaht Vestnik, јајца St.Com.Ist; Tibiscum Studii si Comunicarii. Istorie (ГИ), ↩
- Tibiscum (ИМ), Caransebes ↩
- BerRGK = Bericht der Rémisch-Germanischen Kommission, ↩
- Zbornik Arheologija, Skopje ↩
- Mainz am Rhein ↩
- BHAB BibliothecaHistorica et Archaeologica Banatica, Zbornik Zbornik na trudovi na Štipskiot naroden muzej, Štip ↩
- Timisoara ZRNM = Zbornik Radova Narodnog Muzeja, Belgrad ↩
Zusammenfassung
Analytical Review of the Macedonian Neolithic
Оваа студија нуди анализа на хронологијата на македонскиот неолит од статистичка видна точка, имајќи како извор на информации една база на публикувани, но и непубликувани податоци и информации за неолитските населби од Балканот. Анализата е реализирана имајќи предвид неколку карактеристики на овој период како што се: потеклото, керамичката еволиција и релативната и апсолутната хронологија.
Во оглед на потеклото на македонскиот неолит, ги разгледавме сите дефиниции формулирани до денес во стручната литература.
После факториалните анализи реализирани за распространетоста и еволуцијата на македонскиот неолит можеме да заклучиме дека станува збор за истиот процес на сукцесивни миграции од анадолскиот регион. Днализирајќи ги компаративната и апсолутната (низ призмата на ЧС податоците) хронологија забележуваме дека македонскиот неолит е резултат на истите движења како и во останатите делови од Балканот. Станува збор за четири големи миграции во четири фази и повеќе потфази на развој, но и различни дуфузии, со локални еволуции чија динамика не може секогаш да биде прецизно одредена затоа што публикуваниот материјал е селектиран.
Како заклучок на сето она што го кажав во горенаведените редови за македонскиот неолит, го предлагам хронолошкот систем кој го реализирав во сликата број 11, а кој ја рефлекира комбинацијата на хронолошките системи на I. Лазарович и T. Брегант.
Abreviations
Библиографија
- Angeleski S. 2005, Noi contributii la datarea neoliticului din Macedonia, in Tibiscum ХИ, Caransebes
- Angeleski 5. 2009, Neoliticul2 timpuriu si dezvoltat din Macedonia si zonele invecinate, (PhD. Theses)
- Arandjelovi¢-GaraSanin D. 1954, Starcevacka kultura, Ljubljana
- Aslanis I. 1992, E proistoria thes Makedonias. E neolithique epohi, Athena
- Bartosiewicz L. et al 2001, L. Bartosiewicz, V. Boroneant, C. Bonsal, 5. Stallibras, New data on the prehistoric fauna of the Iron Gates: A case study Schela Cladovei, Romania, in From the mezolithic to the neolithic, Arhaeolingua 11, Budapest
- Benac A. 1989, Neki problemi odnosa Makedonije i zapadnog Balkana u neolitskom dobu, in Maced. acta archaeol. 10, Skopje
- Biagi P. 2005, Updating old concepts on the Relationships between the Balkans and Northern Italy during the Neolithic, 475 vol. IV, Sibiu
- Biagi P. - Spataro M. 2004, Noi datari cu radiocarbon in asezarile culturii Cris din Banat si Transilvania (Romania), in PB III, Timisoara
- Bogdanovié M. 1998, Prilog prouéavanu neolitizacije kontinentalnog dela Balkanskog poluostrova, in Rad1 Dragoslava Srejovica na istrazivanju praistorije Centralnog Balkana (in memoriam), Kragujevac
- Bonsall C. et al 2000, C. Bonsall, G. Cook, R. Lennon, D. Harkness, M. Scott, L. Bartosiewicz, K. McSweeney, Stable isotops, radiocarbon and the mesolithic-neolithic transition in the Iron Gates, in DP XXVI, Ljubljana
- Bregant T. 1968, Ornamentika na neolitski keramiki v Jugoslaviji, Ljubljana
- Brukner B. 1968, Neolit u Vojvodini. Dissertationes V, Belgrad/Novi Sad
- Dimitrijevié 5. 1969, Staréevacka kultura, Vukovar
- Dimitrijevi¢ 5. 1974, Problema stupnjeva startevatke culture 5 posebnim obzirom na doprinos juznopanonskih nalazi8ta reSavanja ovih problema, in Materijali X, Beograd
- Dimitrijevié S. 1978, Neolit u sjeverozapadnoj Hrvatskoj, in Arheoloska istrazivanja и sjeverozapadnoj Hrvatskoj, Zagreb
- Dimitrijevi¢é 5. 1979, Sjeverna zona, in Praistoria jugoslovenskih zemalja, Sarajevo
- Drasovean E. 1989, Observatii pe marginea unor materiale inedite privind raporturile dintre cultura Star%evo-Cris, Vinéa A si lumea lineara in nordul Banatului, in Apulum 26, Alba Iulia
- Drasovean F. 1993, Asezarea neolitica de la Satchinez, in AB (seria noud) И, Timisoara
- Galovié R. 1964, Neue Funde der Staréevo Kultur in Mittel Serbien und Makedonien, in BerRGK, Mainz am Rhein
- Galovi¢ R. 1967, Zelenikovo-Neolitsko naselje kod Skoplja, in ZRNM, vol. VI, Beograd
- Galovi€é R. 1968, Die Staréevo Kultur Jugoslavien. Die Anfange des Neolithikums von Orient bis Nordeuropa, in Fundamenta, F, Reihe A, Band7 3, Ké\n
- GaraSanin D. 1959, Nosa-Biserna Obala, in AP /, Beograd
- GaraSanin D. 1970, Etat actuel et problemes de la prehistoire et de la protohistoire du sud-est europeen, in Astes du II congres congres international des etudes du sud-est europeen, Atena
- GaraSanin D. 1980, Origines et relations des grupes du complexe balcano-pannonien du neolithique ancien, in Problemes de la neolithisation dans certainesregion de |’Europe, Krakow
- GaraSanin D. 1989, Odnos staréevatke grupe prema neolita Makedonije, in Maced. acta archaeol. 10, Skopje
- GaraSanin M. 1959, Neolithikum und Bronzezeit in Serbien und Makedonien, in BerRGK 39, Mainz am Rhein
- GaraSanin M. 1962, Arhelogki prilozi problemu velike egejske seobe, in Diadora vol. 2, Zadar
- GaraSanin M. 1968, Eden osvrt na preistorijata na Makedonija, in GIN/ XII /I Skopje
- GaraSanin M. 1973, Praistorija na tlu SR Srbije, Beograd
- GaraSanin M. 1975, Nekoi problemi na makedonskata praistorija, in Maced. acta archaeol. 1, Skopje
- GaraSanin M. 1979, Centralno Balkanska zona, in P.JZ И ( Neolitsko doba)
- GaraSanin M. 1989, Problemi Neolita i Eneolita centralnog Balkana u vezi sa rezultatima istrazivanja и Makedoniju, in Maced. acta archaeol. 10, Skopje
- GaraSanin M. 1997. Der spite balkanisch-anatolische Komplex-Ein Riickblick nacht vier Jahzehnten, in Starinar vol. XLVII, Beograd
- GaraSanin M. 1998, Kulturstromungen im Neolithikum des sudlichen Balkanraumes, in PZ, Berlin - Leipzig
- GaraSanin M. 1998a, Vinéanska kultura i jadranski uticaji, in Arheolosko blago Kosovo i Metohije od7 Neolita do ranog sradnjeg veka, vol. I & II (katalog), Beograd
- GaraSanin M. - Gara¥anin D. 1959, Iskopavanja и Tarincima na lokalitetu “Vr8nik”, in Zbornik vol. I, Stip
- GaraSanin M. - Gara¥anin D. 1961, Neolitska naselba “Vrénik”1 kaj selo Tarinci, in Zhornik vol. II, Stip
- Garašanin M. - Spasovska G. 1976, Novi iskopuvanja vo Zelenikovo, in Maced. acta archaeol. 2, Prilep
- Georgiev2 Z. - Bilbija M. 1984, Neolitska naselba kaj Govrlevo, in Kulturno nasledstvo vol. IX, Skopje
- Gimbutas M. 1976, Neolithic Macedonia, in Monumenta Archaeologica (Volume one), Los Angeles
- Grbié M. et al 1960, M. Grbié, P. Madkié, 5. Nad, D. Simoska, B. Stalio, Porodin, Bitolj (Bitola)
- Greenfield H. J. - Drasovean E. 1994, Preliminary report on the 1992 excavations at Foeni-Salas an early neolithic Staréevo-Cris settlement in the Romanian Banat, in AB ///, Arheologie-Istorie, Timisoara
- Kitanoski B. 1976, Ranoneolitskata naselba PeSterica kaj Prilep, in Materijali XIV, Prilep
- Kitanoski B. 1977, Neolitska naselba Cuka kaj selo Topoléani, in Maced. acta archaeol. 3, Prilep/Skopje
- Kitanoski B. et al 1978, B. Kitanoski, D. Simoska, J. Todorovié, Novi arheoloski istrazuvanja na naselbata Cuka vo Topoléani kaj Prilep, in Maced. acta archaeol. 4, Prilep
- Kitanoski B. et al 1980, B. Kitanoski, D. Simoska, J. Todorovi¢é, Naselbata PeSterica i problemot na raniot noelit vo Pelagonija, in Maced. acta archaeol. 6, Skopje
- Kitanoski B. et al 1987, B. Kitanoski, D. Simoska, J. Todorovié, Radin Dol-neolitska naselba kaj Prilep, in Maced. acta archaeol. 7-8, Skopje
- Korkuti M. 1995, Neolithikum und Chalkolithikum in Albanien, Heidelberg AW, Mainz am Rhein
- KoroSec J. 1953, Delitev Vincanske kulturne plasti, in AV vol. ИТ, Ljubljana
- Koro§ec P. - KoroSec J. 1973, Predistoriska naselba Barutnica M. kaj Amzibegovo vo Makedonija, Prilep
- Kuzman P. 1990, Zlastrana-neolitska naselba vo Ohrid, in Maced. acta archaeol. 11, Skopje
- Lazarovici C. M.-Lazarovici Gh. 2006, Arhitectura neoliticului si epocii cuprului, vol. 1, Neoliticul, Iasi
- Lazarovici Gh. 1969, Cultura Starcevo-Cris in Banat, in AMN, VI, Cluj-Napoca
- Lazarovici Gh. 1975, Tipologia si cronologia materialului Vincian de la Balta Sarata, in AMN XII, Cluj-Napoca
- Lazarovici Gh. 1977, Gornea-preistorie, Resita
- Lazarovici Gh. 1979, Neoliticul7 Banatului, Cluj-Napoca
- Lazarovici Gh. 1984, Neoliticul timpuriu in Romania, in AMP 8, Zalau
- Lazarovici Gh. 1987/88, Sincronismele Vinca A-Starcevo-Cris, in AMN7 XXIV-XXV, Cluj-Napoca
- Lazarovici Gh. 1993, Les Carpates Meridionales et la Transylvanie, in ANE vol. /, Liége
- Lazarovici Gh. 1995, Uber das Frithneolithikum im sud-Osten Europas (I. Rumanien), in Kulturraum Mittlere und7 Untere Donau. Traditionen und1 Perspektiven des Zusammenlebens Resita
- Lazarovici Gh. 1996, The Proces of the Neolithisation and the Development of the first Neolithic Civilisations in the Balcans, in The Neolithic in the Near East and2 Europe, Collogvium XVI, 9, XII ICPPS, Forli
- Lazarovici Gh. 1998a, About the Neolithisation process of the second migration of the early Neolithic, in BHAB XIV, Timisoara
- Lazarovici Gh. 2006, The Anzabegovo — Gura Baciului Axis and the first stage of the Neolithization process in Southern-central Europe and the Balkans, in Homage to Milutin GaraSanin, Belgrade
- Lazarovici Gh. - Maxim 7. 1995, Gura Baciului, (monografie), Cluj-Napoca
- Luca 5. A. 1985, Sapaturile arheologice de salvare de la Liubcova-Ornita (jud. Carag-Severin), in Banatica 8, Resita
- Luca S. A. 1987b, Așezarea Starčevo-Criş de la Liubcova-Orniţa (săpăturile din anul 1985), in Banatica 9, Reşiţa
- Luca 5. A. 1995, Asezarea de la Turdas-situatia actuala a sitului arheologic (I), in An/CSUS, 2, Sibiu
- Luca S. A. et al 1998, 5. A. Luca, N. Boroffka, M. M. Ciuta, Asezarea neolitica apartinand culturii Staréevo-Cris de la Ordstie-Dealul Pemilor, punct X 8 (campaniile 1993-1994), in Apulwm 35, Alba Iulia
- Luca 5. A. et al 2004, S. A. Luca, C. Roman, D. Diaconeseu, Cercetdri arheologice in pestera Cauce, vol. 1, Sibiu
- Luca 5. A. et al 2005, 5. A. Luca, C. Roman, D. Diaconescu, H. Ciugudean, G. El Susi, C. Beldiman, Cercetdri arheologice in Pestera Cauce, vol. II, Sibiu
- Makkay J. — Starnini E. 2008, The Excavations of Early Neolithic sites of the Kérés culture in the Kérés Valey, Hungary: the final Report, vol1 II The pottery asamblages and III7 The small1 finds, Budapest
- Maxim 7. 1999 Neo-Eneoliticul1 din Transilvania, Cluj-Napoca
- Milojéié V. 1949, Chronologie der jngeren Steinzeit Mittel-und7 Siidosteuropas, Berlin
- Миојче Y. - Zumbusch J., 1971, Die deutsche ausgrabungen auf der Otzaki-Magula in Thesalien I, Das Fruhe Neolithikum - (teil1 IJ), Bonn
- Mitkoski A. 2005, Vrbjanska Cuka kaj seloto Slavej, Prilepsko, in ZA 2, Skopje
- Mock R. E. 1976, The Anza I-III (pre-Vinéa) Ceramics, in Gimbutas M., Neolithic Macedonia, Monumenta Archaeologica (Volume one), Los Angeles
- Pavuk J. 1991, Beitrag zur Definition der Protostar¢evo-Kultur, in Anatolica XIX
- Sanev Y. 1975, Neolitskata naselba Rug Bair kaj 5. Gorubinci, in Zbornik vol. 1V-V, Stip
- Sanev V. 1976, Mlado kameno doba na Makedonija vo dosegaSnite arheoloski istraZuvanja, in Materijali vol. XIV, Prilep
- Sanev V. 1994, Mlado kameno vreme, in AKM vol. 7, Skopje
- Sanev V. 1995, Neolitskite kulturi vo Makedonija, in CPM kniga 2, Skopje
- Sanev V. - Stamenoya M. 1989, Neolitsaka naslba “Stranata” vo selo Angelci, in Zbornik na trudovi, Strumica
- Saney V. et al 1976, V. Sanev, D. Simoska, B. Kitanoski, 5. Sarzoski, Praistorija vo Makedonija (katalog), Skopje
- Simoska D. - Sanev V. 1975, Neolitska naselba Veluška Tumba kaj Bitola, in Maced. acta archaeol. 1, Prilep/Skopje
- Simoska D. - Sanev V. 1977, Neolitska naselba na Mala Tumba kaj selo Trn, Bitola, in Maced. acta archaeol. 3, Prilep/ Skopje
- Simoska D. et al 1979, D. Simoska, B. Kitanoski, J. Todorovié, Neolitska naselba vo Mogila kaj Bitola, in Maced. acta archaeol. 5, Prilep
- Tasié N. -Tomié¢ E. 1969, Crnokalaéka Bara, naselje star¢evatke i vin¢anske kulture, in AJ7 8, Belgrad
- Tasié N. N. 1998, Kriti¢ki osvrt na periodizaciju Starcevacke kulture po Dragoslavu Srejovicu, in Rad12 Dragoslava Srejovica па istrazivanju praistorije centralnog Balkana (in memoriam), Kragujevac
- Tasié N. N. 1998a, Staréevacka kultura, in Arheolosko blago Kosovo i Metohije od1 neolita do ranog sradnjeg veka, vol. 1 & П (katalog), Beograd
- Temelkoski D. - Mitkoski A. 2001, Neolitski antropomorfni statuetki vo predistoriskata zbirka na Zavod i Muzei Prilep, in MH7 nr. 17, Skopje
- Temelkoski D. - Mitkoski A. 2005, Sadova keramika od Vrbjanska Cuka, in Maced. acta archaeol. 16, Skopje
- Temelkoski D. -Mitkoski A. 2006, Praistoriska naselba Mogila Senokos, in Maced. acta archaeol. 17, Skopje
- Vetnié S. 1998, O poreklu Staréevacke2 kulture и basenu Velike Morave, in Rad7 Dragoslava Srejoviéa na istrazivanju praistorije centralnog Balkana (in memoriam), Kragujevac
- Zdravkovyski D. 1988, Istrazuvanje na lokalitetot “Na Breg” selo Mlado Nagoriéane, in Maced. acta archaeol. 9, Skopje
- Zdravkovski D. 1989, Arheologki istrazuvanja na lokalitetot “Atici” vo salo Crnigani, Gevgelisko, in Maced. acta archaeol. 10, Skopje
- Zadraykovyski D. 1990, Za granicite na Anzabegovo - Vrsni¢kata kulturna grupa vo sredniot neolit, in Maced. acta archaeol. 11, Skopje
- Zdravkovski D. 1993, Neolitska naselba “Cubuk Ce&ma” kaj selo Nikugtak, Kumanovo, in Maced. acta archaeol. 13, Skopje
- Zdravkoyski D. 1995, Middle Neolithic in the region of Skopje, in ZA, Skopje
- Zdravkovski D. 2004, Sreden neolit vo Gorno Vardarskiot region, MA theses, Skopje
- Zdravkovski D. 2006, Geneza i razvoj na Anzabegovo - Vrsnickata grupa, PhD. Theses, Skopje