Macedoniae acta archaeologica 10 (1989) · стр. 55–78
Прелиминарна анализа на животинските коскени остатоци од неолитска та населба Тумба Маџари близу Скопје
Содржина
- SKOPJE (YUGOSLAVIA)
- INTRODUCTION
- ARCHEOLOGICAL INFORMATION ON THE SITE
- Tumba Madzari, Zoomorphic cult depictions out of baked earth
- GENERAL CHARACTERISTICS OF THE OSTEOLOGICAL MATERIAL
- METHODS OF MATERIAL ANALYSIS
- Phot. 3 Sheep skull (upper) and goat skull (lower) with horn-cores hacked off
- RESULTS OF ANALYSIS OF THE OSTEQLOGICAL MATERIAL
- Tab ela 2, Distribution of osteological material in the huts and outside the huts
- MORPHOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT OF ANIMALS
- Cattle and aurochs
- PHALANX II
- PHALANX Ш
- 5 MAA
- TIBIA
- T able5S. Dimensions of aurochs bones
- Pig and boar
- METATARSUS III + IV
- Domestic goat
- Small ruminant (probably mufflon)
- T a Бе! a 13. Dimensions of red deer bones
- DISCUSSION
PRELIMINARY ANALYSIS OF BONE REMNANTS OF ANIMALS FROM THE NEOLITHIC ARCHAEOLOGICAL SITE TUMBA MADZARI NEAR
SKOPJE (YUGOSLAVIA)
INTRODUCTION
The views on the sites, where the earliest traces of domestication of animals can be found in Europe, have been radically changed after the discovery of early neolithic sites in Greece in Argisa-Magula in the layer of preceramic neolithic age (Boessneck, 1962), and in Nea Nikomedeia (Higgs, 1962). Since that time the region of the southern part of the Balkan Peninsula has become the country of particular interest for the archaeozoologists. The southern part of Yugoslavia (Macedonia) belonging to this area is still relatively little known. Вокопут (1976) published an extensive and very interesting osteological material from an early neolithic site in Anza, and Schwartz (1976) described a similar material from the Rug Bair site in the vicinity of Anza.
Since several years archaeozoological investigations have been conducted in several neolithic sites in the Pelagonia Valley and at the MadZari site near Skopje.
The present work is the first publication from a cycle of these investigations.
ARCHEOLOGICAL INFORMATION ON THE SITE
Although the material treated is out of the frames of the basic problems, we considered that it was necessesary to bring forward some basic data for a better general view of Tumba MadzZari, namely concerning the character, the chronology and the cultural importance of this site, discovered with the systematic archaelogic research which has been going in the past several years.
As it is mentioned in the introductory text, Tumba Madjari is located in the vicinity of Skopje, in the Skopje plain surrounded by the slopes of the mountain Skopska Crna Gora. The site is erected in an environment with geomorphic and other conditions which allowed the neolithic man to exist. Furthermore, it is located into the larger plain in Macedonia in the north part, which with its geographic position allowed a free economic and cultural communication with the other territories in the central Balkan zone, the Aegean coast and western Thrace. (V. Sanev 1988).
The trial excavation conducted in 1978 had shown that Tumba Madjari is a site which has a form of a sliced cone with a radius cca. 220 m. and a 3 m. hight in the central area. It is similar to the settlements known as Tumbi in Pelagonia or the other plain areas in the Balkan which are known as „тарија“, ,,tell“, ,,selilshna торија“ or similar. In the vertical stratigraphy of the cultural layer, thich 2.80 т., three horizons were stated, with remains of living, confined with leveling layers, which means that the settlement was renewed three times. The character of the discovered archaelogic finds, the typologic features of the pottery gave the essential chronological and cultural scales, according to which Tumba Madjan was found and developed in the internal middle neolithic phase known as Anzabegovo-Vrshnik group (II-IV) from the East Macedonian neolith (V. GaraSanin 1979).
Considering the importance of the results for the future research of the neolithic period in the plain of Skopje and wider, since 1981 a complexed investigation has been undertaken of the last strata (III) in the western part of the settlement, with a special accent on the architecture and the organization of the living space. To Ithis day when the osteologic analysis is presented, remains of four large and massive structure ruins have been uncovered, of which three living quarters and one shrine. (V. Sanev 1988) The houses were built one next to the nother separated by narrow alleys and small court yards with an east-west orientation. They have a square or a rectangular base with an appriximate size 9 x 9,7 x 8m. or8 x 10 т. with a clay pressed floor and in the interior oval hearths were found and dome like furnices, as well as built altar tables. According to the remains of the plastering prints from the walls, it is quite visible that the houses were built with a massive wooden construction like the other houses in the neolithic settlements. A special feature of these homes that the interior walls had relief decorative ornamented plastering. The houses and the entire settlement were distroyed by fire, but the couses are still unkown to us.
Under the ruins of the houses and around them different archaeologic finds were found, of which the pottery finds are the most numerous. The pottery is in a high technology and artistis leves. The vessals have various forms as to their application (for storage of food and its preparation, for liquide and for ceremonial means) decorated with the impresso and the barbotine ornamentation, and painted with dark brown colour on a red basis. We specially separate the vessals which were popular among the inhabitansis, vessals with a form of ascos, amphora shaped ones or cup like, ones decorated with linear geometric motives with a high artistic rendering.
The objects for the ritual needs, as well as the shrine structure which have been discovered for the first time in a settlement of this period, throw a new limelight in the knowlage and the interpretation of the religious life of the inhabitants. Of importance is the new depiction of the Supreme Mother Goddess, that besides the symbol of fertility has other devine aspects. Quite interesting are the zoomorphic figures of domestic animals, which fulfil the general meaning and the aims for survival.
Besides the finds from the material production of importance for the ur.covering of the economic conditions and the organization of the trade, also have the remains of cerial seeds and the bones of animals. These remains were discovered in the homes and outside of them, and speek of the relation of the population and their activity in obtaining food, and about the relation of agriculture to farming.
The analysis of the animal bone remains which will fallow up, will be a valuble contribution to the understanding of the economic life of the settlement, and allso the first view of the fauna in the Skopje plain in the middle neolithic period. Tumba Madzari, A ground-plan of the discovered houses from excavation campaings 1981-1985
Tumba Madzari, Zoomorphic cult depictions out of baked earth
GENERAL CHARACTERISTICS OF THE OSTEOLOGICAL MATERIAL
Bone remnants discovered in the layer called ,,horizon I“ at the MadZari Tumba site are mostly kitchen waste. This is evidenced by numerous traces of bone hacking and traces of cuts made with a sharp tool suggesting meat carving (Phot. 1). Traces of bone contact with high temperature (burnt bone) are present. Besides traces of fragmentation of bones connected with meat consumption traces of purposeful working out of bones are found. They were few, usually in the form of partial smoothing out of fragments of bones or antlers, without converting them into useful tools (Phot. 2).
The third type of traces of bone hacking suggests procedures connected either with the need of obtaining of horn-cores of small ruminants or with religious
Phot. 1 Phalanx | of domestic cattle with traces of cuts Phot. 2 A fragment of red deer antler (upper part) and
ulnar bone of cattle (lower part) with traces of working
procedures (Phot. 3). These traces indicated that the horn-cores were hacked off from the skulls of sheep and goats by a rather uniform technique. The horn-cores were hacked off at the base with a small fragment of the cranium. This was done, probably, using a sharp and heavy tool, since the remaining traces appear frequently as if this hacking-off was done with one blow. This might have been connected also with the preparation of meat for consumption if the heads of the animals were eaten.
During the time of lying in the soil many bone remnants became fossilized which often blurred the details of the natural surface of the bones causing difficulties in their identification, Despite this, the proportion of the identified bone fragments was very high, amounting to 92.2% in the whole material from the horizont I layer. This was directly related to the generally good condition of these bones, which means that bone fragments were fairly large and were not crumbling.
METHODS OF MATERIAL ANALYSIS
The few bones preserved whole and the morphologically mature epiphyses were measured according to the principles of the international measuring technique (von den Driesch, 1976). On the basis of the measured dimensions the withers height of the animals, from which these bones were derived, was calculated using appropriate coefficients. In the case of the dimensions of the bones of cattle and sheep the absolute values of these dimensions were converted to point scores by the method used for cattle by Lasota-Moskalewska (1985) and for the pig by Lasota-Moskalewska, Kobryn and Swiezynski (1987).
The osteological material from the layer called horizon I at the MadZari Tumba site was divided into groups differing in their location: hut 1 or the so called offering place and its nearest vicinity, hut 2 and a hollow near it, hut 3, hut 4 and a group of bones not connected with any hut in their location. This group icluded also bone remnants collected from the nearest vicinity of huts 2,3,4. The composition of the osteological material in the huts and outside the huts was compared with respect to the animal species. The comparative analysis was based most frequently on the per cent proportions. In case of necessity the homogenity of the material was checked using correlation tables, and the results were tested by the chi square test. The significance of differences or deficiencies of particular bones as shown in the
table were tested by the y test (G6éralski, 1964). The significance of the differences in the proportions of burnt bones in various groups of the osteological material were tested by the chi square test using the formula:
with v = 1
where: n,n — number of animals in the compared groups
JI, Jz - probability of finding bone from each compared group. The results of the analysis of animal remnants from the MadzZari site were compared with the results of archaeozoological investigations at the Anza site dated to 6100-5000 BC, that is early neolithic period (Békényi, 1976).
Phot. 3 Sheep skull (upper) and goat skull (lower) with horn-cores hacked off
Phot. 4 Differentiation of the size of phalanx I in cattle. From the left to the right: Bos primigenius, Bos taurus primigenius, third and fourth —Bos taurus brachyceros
(dwarfism)
RESULTS OF ANALYSIS OF THE OSTEQLOGICAL MATERIAL
In the material derived from the layer called horizon I, it was possible to identify 2847 remnants of mammals (Table 1). The 240 non-identified remnants accounted for only 7.8% of all remnants of mammals. Besides that, 14 fragments of human bones and 4 bird bones were found. Other remnants were from fish (22 fish bones) and 8 fragments of the shells (Unio sp). In the group of mammalian bones 2689 fragments belonged to domesticated mammals, and only 158 to wild ones (5.5%). The most frequently found bones of the wild animals belonged to the red bear and aurochs, followed by those which belonged to the boar and hare. The third group of less frequently found bones were those of the horse or ass and probably mufflon. The first two species were identified by the size of the bones, since the remaining remnants had no features making possible a more precise identification. The possibility cannot be ruled out that the remnants belonged to other animals from the Equidae genus (e. g. onager, kulan, kiang). The bones placed in the table as derived from wild sheep or goats require also some explanation. There were seven bone fragments evidently bigger than the bones of sheep and domesticated goats. Their structure was more compact and the external relief was more sharp. Unfortunately, a precise identification of the species was not possible, in view of fragmentary material. It is supposed that these were the bones of mufflons (Ovis ammon gmelini). Among the bones of wild animals those of the roe deer (Capreolus capreolus), the elk (Alces alces), the wolf (Canis lupus) and a rodent were sporadically found. One of these rodent bones remained unrecognized, but the other one was identified as a fragment of the cranium of the great mole—rat (Spalanx, Gueldenstaedt, 1770). Among the remnants of the domesticated animals those of sheep and goats were most frequent (48.12% ) Sheep bones occurred 4.4 times more frequently than those of goats. Cattle remnants were accounting for 41.06% of the whole material, that is they were nearly as frequently observed as
cases they were derived from young animals. The remnants of sheep and goats were equally numerous. It is worth stressing that 30% of the remnants of these animals were bones of the skull and teeth. One goat skull had the horn—-cores hacked off. Only one bone fragment was that of a dog. Besides mammalian bones one bird bone was found.
In hut 2 the identified material included 61 bones of domesticated mammals and 9 bones of wild mammals (8 red deer bones and 1 bone of an aurochs). Besides that, three human bones and two clam shells were found. It seems that the bones of cattle, sheep and goats were in similar proportions, but pig bones were absent. Beside this hut a pit was found from which a small group of animal bones were collected. The composition of this group was without any peculiarities apart from the fact that this was the only site where fish remnants were demonstrated.
In hut 3 the number of identified bones was 130, and 6.2% of them were derived from wild mammals. Among the bones of domesticated animals the remnants of sheep and goats accounted for 62.3%, those od cattle for 32.8% , and those of pigs for only 4.1%.
In hut 4 the number of identified bone fragments was 107,11 of them were those of the hare. No other bones of wild animals were found. Bones of sheep and goats prevailed among the remnants of domesticated animals (51%), the number of cattle bones was lower 38.5% , and 9,4% of bones were those of pigs. In the soil outside the huts 2200 remnants of domesticated animals and 120 remnants of wild animals were demonstrated (5.2%). In this group of remnants of domesticated animals 46.3% were those of sheep and goats, and 42.2% were bovine bones. Pig bones accounted for 11.0% and dog bones for 0.5% only. Among the bones of wild animals the species proportions were nearly identical as that reported above in the discussion of the general characteristics of the osteological material derived from the layer called horizon I.
In the soil outside the huts, apart from the above enumerated bones, ien parts of human skeleton, three bird bones, and six fragments of shells of a fresh water clam were discovered.
Tab ela 2, Distribution of osteological material in the huts and outside the huts
In the individual huts the number of bones found was too small that these groups could be compared. At the same time, however, it would be difficult to let the question being unanswered — whether the osteological material found in the huts was different from that outside the huts. To answer this question the bones from the huts 2, 3, 4 were pooled, and were considered later as one set, which did not contain the bones from the so called place of offerings and its closest vicinity and from the pit near hut 2. This grouping of the material was based on archeological premises. The groups of remnants from the huts and from outside the huts were analysed using a corelation table (Table 2). The assumed zero hypothesis was that these materials were homogenous with respect to the proportions of the remnants of cattle, pigs and sheep and goats considered jointly. The chi square test showed that this hypothesis should be dismissed x = 12.8 13y7a = 9.21 with v = 2 Using the test y (Céralski 1964) it was found also that the material from the huts contained significatly more bones of sheep and goats and significantly less pig bones. The participation of wiid animal bones in the huts was 9.1% and in the soil outside the huts it was 5,4%. This difference may be without importance in view of the small number of bones of wild animals.
The comparison of the proportion of the remnants of young animals showed that in the huts as well as outside them the per cent of the bones of young cattle was similar (Table 3). The proportions of bones of sziall ruminants also seem to be similar. Evident differences were revealed only in the bones of pigs, since the proportions of bones of young animals was higher in the huts. It is difficult to say whether this difference was of any greater importance or was due to the small number of pigs, especially in the huts.
The proportions were compared also of bone remnants with traces of burning in the huts and outside them. The proportion of the former ones was 8.0%, that of the latter 1.6%. This difference is rather not accidental. Its testing by a form of the shisquare test confirmed this supposition (x = 45.76>7a = 0.01 =6.6with v=1). It may be said that in the huts the number of bones with traces of burning was significantly greater.
MORPHOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT OF ANIMALS
Cattle and aurochs
In the whole material of cattle bones (Table 4) only one metatarsal bone was preserved as whole. This was a bone of a male and its length made possible calculation of the withers heigh of the animal using the coefficient of Pock (1966). This height was 136.5 cm and this shows that the animals belonged to big cattle. Other dimensions of bones were measured in fragments of bones or in such bones whici: are unsuitable for calculation of withers height.
MANDIBULA
length of the cheektooth row = 155
SCAPULA
smallest length of the collum scapulae
length of the glenoid cavity
63 - 59 62 67
breadth of the gleoid cavity
52 - 50 51 55
HUMERUS
breadth of the distal end = 76,81,81,84,86,86
RADIUS
Breadth of the proximal end =
Breadth of the distal end =
METACARPUS III + IV
breadth of the proximal end =
breadth of the distal end =
57,58, 58, 59, 59, 62,63, 68, 69,
TIBIA
breadth of the proximal end = 107
breadth of the distal end = 57, 67
PATELLA
length = 69
CALCANEUS
length = 132, 135
TALUS
length
55 70 72 (79)
breadth of the distal end
33 41 45 (49)
METATARSUS III + IV
length
246
breadth of the proximal end
- 45,48,50,52,56,58
breadth of the distal end
PHALANX I
length
43 46 47 48 48 59 60 63 63 63 63 63
breadth of the proximal end
22 25 22 25 35 29 30 28 29 32 30 33
breadth of the distal end
19 21 18 22 30 29 29 28 27 30 29 32 63 64 64 65 65 65 65 66 67 68 69 70 31 29 33 32 29 30 28 33 40 34 33 35 30 26 29 29 29 29 27 28 37 30 32 32
PHALANX II
length = 38,39 ,40,40,41,41 42,42,42 43,44 44,44 ,45,45,45,45 ,45,45,45,45,47,47
PHALANX Ш
63 68 69 73 77 80 80 81 84
diagonal length od the sole
53 56 57 58 59 61 63 68 67
length of the dorsal surface,
32 34 35 35 36 37 38 43 42
height
Table 4. Dimensions of domestic cattle bones
5 MAA
The joint assessment of the size and type of cattle raised by the neolithic - population in MadzZari was done by the point method (Fig. 1). This assessment suggests that the main group of dimensions was in the range from 38 to 92 points. That means that these dimensions were of medium or high values. Besides that a group of very small dimensions, from 7 to 23 points, was isolated. This group had no common features with the main one. It is worth stressing that each point in the scale represents an arbitrary dimension of the bone which cannot be regarded as characterizing the whole individual. Thus the observed distribution cannot be regarded as a distribution of withers height in the population of cattle. This is the distribution of the size of various parts of cattle skeleton. One individual might have had certain skeletal parts big and other parts of intermediate size, and could thus represent a mixed pattern of somatic features.
Taking into consideration this explanation it may be said that in the group of 72 analysed dimensions 37.5% were estimated as large ones, 52.8% as intermediate, and 9.7% as small.
In a similar conversion of the dimensions of aurochs bones to points two groups could be again isolated (Table 5). One of these groups was from 68 to 90 points and the second one was over 100 points. The number of available dimensions of aurochs was much smaller than that of cattle dimensions, and one could not be
RADIUS :
breadth of the distal end = 83,96.
METACARPUS III + IV
length 209
breadth of the proximal end 70 68,68,71,73
breadth of the distal end 74
breadth of the diaphysis 42
TIBIA
breadth of the distal end = 70,75
TALUS
lenth 81
breadth of the distal end 57
METACARPUS III + IV
breadth of the proximal end = 53
PHALANX I
length 72 74
breadth of the proximal end 41 41
breadth of the distal end 38 41
T able5S. Dimensions of aurochs bones
certain whether the isolation of two groups was not accidental. However, one doubtless fact is emphasized, that the dimensions of aurochs bones fall within the category of cattled dimensions accepted as large. The recognition of aurochs bones was based on morphological non-metric features which are not regarded as an absolute criterium. In this identification the possibility of errors cannot be ruled out. In one case on the basis of the length of metacarpal bones III+IV the withers height of the aurochs was calculated.
In view of absence of conversion coefficients for aurochs bones those for cattle were used. The withers height calculated in this way was 128.8 cm, thus this was a rather small aurochs, such as big domestic cattle.
Pig and boar
The analysed pig bones were mainly in fragments (Table 6), the only whole bone was the astragalus, and it served for calculation of the withers height of the animal (Teichert 1966/69). This height was 60.9 cm, thus the pig was very small.
Similarly as in the case of cattle a joint evaluation of pig bones was carried out according to the point scale. The dimensions were in the range from 10 to 30 points. Thus pigs were medium sized or large.
The dimensions of the bones of boars were in points 67 and 72, that means that they were very small (Table 7). The smali dimensions of the boars are evidenced also by the calculated withers height of one of them which was 94.9 cm. One of the measured bone fragments was from an animal which was a transitional form between domestic pig and boar.
SCAPULA
smallest length of the collum scapulae 18 20
length of the glenoid cavity - 26
breadth of the glenoid cavity - 21
HUMERUS
breadth of the distal end 35 36 39
breadth of the trochlea 26 25 30
RADIUS
breadth of the proximal end = 25,26
TIBIA
breadth of the proximal end = 47
breadth of the distal end = 28
TALUS
length = 34
Table 6. Dimensions of domestic pig bones SCAPULA smallest length of the collum scapulae 28 length of the glenoid cavity 39 breadth of the glenoid cavity 32 RADIUS breadth of the proximal end = 41 TALUS length = 53
Table 7. Dimensions of boar bones Sheep
On the basis of the length of whole bones (Table 8) the withers height was calculated of eight sheep using appropriate coefficients of Teichert (quoted after Drisch and Boessneck, 1974). The scatter of values was fairly broad, from 50.4 to 66.6 m. The sheep were small or medium sizes. The cranial fragments showed that an overwhelming majority of sheep had horns (males as well as females). Skulls of hornless sheep were found also, but they were scarce.
MANDIBULA
length of the cheektooth row 69 71 73
inf-goc - 160 162
HUMERUS
length 155
length from caput 135 111
breadth of the distal end
31 26 26,28,28,28,29,30
RADIUS
length 145 146
breadth of the proximal end 29 29 28,
26 25 24,27, 27,28,28
breadth of the distal end
breadth of the diaphysis
15 16 14,14,14,15,15,16,17,18
METACARPUS III + IV
length 113 125 131
breadth of the proximal end 20 21 19,20,21,23,23 -
breadth of the distal end 22 23 21,24 -
breadth of the diaphysis 12 12 -
TIBIA
breadth of the distal end = 22
TALUS
length 26
breadth of the distal end 17
METATARSUS III + IV
length 111 117
breadth of the proximal end 19 21 19,19, 20,22
breadth of the distal end 23 27 22
breadth of the diaphysis 12 14
WITHERS HEIGHT
BASIS OF CALCULATION cm
Metacarpus Ш-ЕГУ 53,3 64,1 66,5
Metatarsus III+IV 50,4 53,0
Humerus 66,5
Radius 58,3 58,7
Table 8. dimensions of domestic sheep bones
Domestic goat
Three whole metacarpal bones (Table 9) served for calculation of the withers heights of domestic goats (Schramm, 1967). This height varied from 58.6 to 67.8 cm. No fragments of hornless skulls of goats were found. Males and females had horns.
Small ruminant (probably mufflon)
Four fragments were measured of radial bones, slightly bigger than those of sheep and domestic goat (Table 10). With full certainty the roe deer could be excluded, although the structure of the boner and its external relief suggested that the bones had belonged to wild animals. The bones were compared with the similar bones of the capricorn, chamois, several antelopes and mufflon from the collection of skeletons in the Agricultural Academy in Warsaw. The appearance of these
HUMERUS
breadth of the distal end =
RADIUS
breadth of the proximal end =
METACARPUS III + IV
length
24 25 26 29,
breadth of the proximal end
breadth of the distal end
15 16 18 19,
breadth of the diaphysis
WITHERS HEIGHT
BASIS OF CALCULATION
58,6,65,0,67,8
Metacarpus III+IV
Table 9. Dimensions of domestic goat bones
RADIUS
breadth of the proximal end
breadth of the diaphysis
breadth of the diaphysis
small wild ruminant
Table 10. Dimensions of bones of
RADIUS
breadth of the proximal end =
breadth of the distal end =
48
TALUS
length = 59
breadth = 64
Table 11. Dimensions of ass bones
HUMERUS
length
135
breadth of the distal end
RADIUS
length
breadth of the proximal end
breadth of the distal end
breadth of the diaphysis
WITHERS HEIGHT
BASIS OF CALCULATION
Humerus
Radius
Table 12. Dimensions of dog bones
bones resembled that of mufflon’s bones, and their dimensions were also similar. The widht of the proximal epiphysis of the radius in mufflons was 30 mm in females and 33 mm in males, the width of its shaft was 17 mm in females and 20 mm in male, the thickness of the shaft was 11 mm in female and 13 mm in male. Considering that the skeletons belonged to the animals from zoological gardens it may bee supposed that these animals were somewhat smaller than those living at large.
SCAPULA
length of the collum scapulae 37 38
length of the glenoid cavity 44 45
breadth of the glenoid cavity 42 43
HUMERUS
breadth of the distal end = 59,61,63
RADIUS
breadth of the distal end = 53,55
PHALANX I
BRS
RBS
Length
breaclth of the puohimal end
breaclth of clistal end
PHALANX II
length = 41,43,48,48
T a Бе! a 13. Dimensions of red deer bones
Dog
On the basis of two whole long bones of these dogs the withers height was calculated (Koudelka, 1885). Both dogs were small, their withers height was 40.2 and 45.5 cm.
The dimensions of the bones of other animals are presented in Table 11 and 13, but in view of the small number of t hese data it would be difficult to describe the morphology of the animals from which these bones were derived.
DISCUSSION
The archaeozoological analysis shows that the basic source of meat for the population of MadzZari in the middle neolithic period were do.nesticated animals. The wild animals were a supplementary sourse and the animals hunted mainly were: red deer, aurochs and boar. Probably these animals were common in the natural enviroment of MadZari, and their large meat mass encouraged their hunting. Hunting of the aurochs and boar had an additional advantage: after killing of the adults animals the young ones could be caught and added to the domestic animals. Since their domestication was mostly successful, this could increase the number of domestic animals (Bökönyi, 1983). Birds were, most assuredly, no stabile source of meat. The role of fish in the diet of this human population is uncertain. The number of fish remnants was much grater than that of bird remnants, but the former were found at only one site, that is in the pit of unknown destination. This may suggest that thay were not the usual kitchen waste. Several fragments of clam shells (Unio sp) may be an accidental find, but prehaps shellfish were collected in rivers for eating or for feeding them to pigs. Among the domesticated animals the main source of meat were ruminants, sheep. goats and cattle. The sheep seems to have been the commonest domestic animal. The ratio of sheep to goats was 4.4:1. This proportion has been confirmed in the osteological material in Anza (BOkOnyi, 1976), where sheep bones were six times more frequently found than those of goats. At the Anza site in eastern Macedonia, dated to 6-7 millenia B.C.. the proportion of small ruminants was much greater than that of cattle and pigs, and greater than in Madžari. This seems to be connected with an earlier beginning of the settlement in Anza. In this connection one may suppose that the economy at this beginning could have a predominance of animal breeding over farming, while in Madzari these proportions might have been more balanced. Cattle breeding may be connected with the presence of a population working in agriculture, stabilized with regard to established living sites and possessing meadows with a rich flora. Cattle was for this population a condition for agriculture development, since Being a source of meat and milk, cattle was also supplying drawing force and provided manure. We should not forget however, that in MadzZari also the husbandry of sheep and goats prevaild (although only slightly). The sheep were of small and medium size, smaller than in Anza, and were differentiated morphologically, which might be an evidence of varying progression of their domestication. It is assumed generally that the European domestic sheep and goats came here at the beginning of the neolithic period from south-western Asia. In the material in Madzari several bone fragments were found, which were suspected of having belonged to wild small ruminants, and they resembled most the bones of mufflons. Unfortunately. they were not sufficiently characteristic that we could be certain that in neolithic — Macedonia the wild type of sheep was present.
Should the above suggestion be confirmed by finding mufflon’s skull, then we could consider the possibility of a local domestication of this species.
The domesticiation of cattle and pigs 5 easier to explain. The wild form of cattle, that is the aurochs, was fairly frequent in the neolithic period in Macedonia. Aurochs remnants were found in Madzari as well as in Anza. The size of these animals was similar in both these localities. Two groups were isolated, one was the size of big domestic cattle, the other was slightly bigger. Probably, this was due to sexual differences (dimorphism). but it might have been caused also to a division into the proper aurochs type and the intermediate form, which was a link between the wild and the domesticated cattle. Especially in Anza the occurrence of such forms was very likely, since the author included into the group of domestic cattle also very big animals, of equal size as the animals in the group of bigger aurochs. Because the Anza settlement was older, the number and the size of the intermediate forms might have been greater than in MadZari. The cattle in MadZari varied greatly in size (Phot 4). Cattle of medium size and large size prevailed. A similar distribution was found in the material from Anza. This differentiation was due, doubtlessly, to differeces in the stage of domestication of the animals. In the group of big cattle the pure form of Bos taurus primigenius was, doubtlessly, present, in the medium-size group the animals might have had already the features of Bos taurus brachyceros.
In the material from MadzZari attenuon is called to an isolated group of very small cattle. The explanation that these were pathological types is not likely, because they accounted for 10% of the found animals. Were this group a result of individual variability, then its continuity with the main group could be detected. This cattle may be compared only with the dwarf cattle described in Africa by Epstein (1971). 100 | | 100 |
Fig. 2 Dimensions of the bones of pigs and boars on the point scale
Fig.1 Dimensions of the bones of cattle (A) and aurochs (B) on the point scale
group with inherited growth defect or would be a drastic effect of inbreeeding. In the neolithic period in Madzari the pig was in the last place among the animals bred for consumption. In Anza also the pig was in consumption and probably also in breeding the least popular species. As already mentioned, the pig was the species most likely domesticated locally. This supposition is suggested by a relatively high number of boar bones indicating that the animal was hunted frequently and its offsprings were possibly domesticated. Yet stronger evidence supportind this hypothesis is finding of a from intermediate between the domestic pig and the boar. The domestic pig was raised, probably, in some isolation from the natural environment, since the adult animals were much smaller than the wild ones. The domestic pigs were raised rather for a short time, and were killed earlier than the ruminants, as evidenced by the highest per cent of bones of animals morphologically immature. This is understandable considering that the only purpose of their In the MadZari site a difference was found between the material from the huts and from outside the huts. In the huts the number of sheep and goat remnants was significantly greater and the number of pig remnants was significantly lower. This would be difficult to explain as a result of consumption purposes, since it would be difficult to suppose that the animals of one species were eaten in huts and other ones outside the huts. In the huts also the number of singed bones was also greater. Considering these two facts jointly it could be imagined that in the huts sacrifices were made with burnt-offerings. The offered animals might be sheep or goats and their singed remnants were left in the huts. lt is worth stressing, that in the so called offering site and in its close vicinity the proportion of sheep and goat remnants was also greatest. In many cases traces were found left by cutting off the horn-cores from the skulls of sheep and goats. This fact in connection with the above ones may be considered as a religious procedure. The pertinent literature provides many descriptions of similar procedures in cases of animals buried (as the subject or object of religious cult). This was observed in the whole Europe and not only in the neolithic period but also in later times (Behrens, 1964: Zimermann, 1970; Lasota — Moskalewska, 1977; Wegrzynowicz 1982).
Archaeological investigations at the MadZari site will be continued for exploration of lower layers which will certainly help in solving of the problems outlined in this paper.
Белешки
- is difficult to establish whether the dwarf cattle came to neolithic-era Macedonia from other regions or developed here. In the latter case, it would be a raising was obtaining of meat. ↩
Summary
Preliminary Analysis of Bone Remnants of Animals from the Neolithic Archaeological Site Tumba Madzari near Skopje (Yugoslavia)
Since several years, archaeozoological investigations have been conducted at several neolithic-age sites in southern Yugoslavia (Macedonia). The present study is the first publication on this cycle of investigations. It deals with the osteological materials from the MadzZari Tumba site (near Skopje) dated in middle neolithic period. The analysed animal remnants were from the layer called Horizont I.
Nearly all remnants had the character of kitchen waste. They were obtained from isolated places, called huts, and from the soil outside these huts. One of the huts was, probably, aso called place of offerings connected with some religious cult.
The total number of identified remnants comprised 2847 belonging to mammals, 4 bird bones, 22 fish bones and 8 fragments of shells of a fresh-water clam (Unio sp). The archaeozoological analysis demonstrated that the main meat source for the MadZari population in the neolithic period were domesticated mammals. The meat of wild animals was only a small supplement (5.5%). The hunted animals were mainly the aurochs, the red deer and the boar. The domesticated animals were mainly sheep and goats (48.1%), and cattle (41,1%) much less frequently pigs (10.6%). This composition of the domestic animals suggests that the type of economy of the population was mixed — agricultural and animal breeding.
Sheep were kept more frequently than goats, the quantitative ration of their remnants was 4.4:1. These animals varied greatly morphologically. Their withers height ranged from 50 to 66 cm. Usually they had horns, although hornless sheep were sporadically found. The withers height of the goats was 59 and 68 cm. Males and females had always horns.
The cattle belonged in 37% to the big type (probably Bos taurus primigenius) and to the medium-big type (53.0%) which might have had a mixture of the features of the Bos taurus primigenius and Bos taurus brachyceros. Besides them a pure type of Bos taurus bracnyceros was found. Another separately identified group (10.0% ) of very small size of the bones was called-dwarf cattle. The remnants of the aurochs indicated that most of these animals were the size of big domestic cattle, and only some of them were bigger. This may be an indirect evidence that cattle domestication was a local process and that it was continued even at the time of functioning of the Madžari settlement. At the same time, a large part of the cattle were already in an advanced stage of domesticarion.
The pig represented an advanced stage of domestication since it differed evidently in its size from the boar. An intermediate form between'the pig and the boar was also present, which suggests also that the process of domestication of the boar could occur locally.
A comparative analysis was carried out of the osteological materijal from the huts (No 2+3+4) and.from the soil outside the huts. These materials were not homogenous with respect to the proportion of the refhnants of cattle, pigs, sheep and goats.
In the huts a significant surplus was found of the bones of sheep and goats, with a significantly lower number of pig bones. In the huts the number of singed bones was also greater. These differences might have been connected with the religious cult practised by the population of MadzZari. It is supposed that sheep and goats more frequently than other animals were offered to the deities. This supposition is supported by the fact that at the so called place of offerings the bones of small ruminants prevailed greatly over the other ones. The finding of the skulls of sheep and goats with cut off horn-cores might be due also to religious procedures, especially considering that similar procedures had been described frequently in the pertinent literature.
Библиографија
- Behrens H. 1964 Die neolithisch — friihmetallzeitlichen Tierskelettfunde der Alten Welt, Berlin.
- Boessneck J. 1962 Die Tierreste aus der Argissa~-Magula vom prikeramischen Neolithicum bis zur mitleleren Bronzezeit. In: Milojcic V. Boessneck J., Hopf M.: apne aged, Bonn, pp 27-29
- Bokényi 5. 1976 The Vertebrate Fauna fron Anza. In.: Gimbutas M.: Neolithic Macedonia, Los Angeles, California, pp. 313-363 1983 Domestication, Dispersal and Use of Animal in Europe, ,,World Animal Science“, Al, Ed. Peel L. and Tribe D.E., Elsevier, Amsterdam-Oxford-New York-Tokyo, pp. 1-20
- Driesch A. von den 1976 A guide to the measurement of animal bones from archaeological sites, Peabody Museum Bulletin 1, Driesch A. von den und Boessneck J. 1974 Kritische Anmerkungen zur WiderristhShenberechnung aus Langenmasen vor-und friihgeschichtlicher Tierknochen, Sdugetierkundliche Mitteilungen, 22, Miinchen, pp. 325-348
- Epstein H. 1971 ‘The origin of the Domestic Animals of Africa, v. 1 Leipzig
- Fock J. 1966 Metrische Untersuchungen an Metapodien einiger europaischer Rinderrassen, Miinchen.
- GaraSanin M. , 1979 Praistorija Jugoslovenskih zemalja Centralnobalkanska zona, II, Sarajevo, pp. 84-106.
- Goralski A. 1966 Kryterium Ч oceny istotnosci nadwyzki i niedoboru liczebnosci w elementarnej kostce wielodzielczej m—wymiarowej tablicy, Zeszyty Naukowe Politechniki Warszawskiej, 131, pp 7- 32.
- Higgs E.S. 1962 Fauna. In.: Rodden R.J.: Excavations at the Early Neolithic Site at Nea Nikomedeia, Greek Macedonia (1961 season). Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society, 28, pp. 271-274.
- Koudelka F. 1885 Das Verhiltnis der Ossa longa zur Skeletthdhe bei den Saugetieren. Verhandl.d. Nauturforsch. Ver Brinn, 24, pp. 127-153.
- Lasota-Moskalewska A. 1977 Ocena morfologiczna kosci bydlecych z Gajowizny In.: ed: Kowalczyk J. Cmentarzysko kultury amfor kulistych w Zlotej Sandomierskiej, Wroclaw-Warszawa-Krak6w-Gdansk, pp. 97- 132. 1985 The skeleton of a prehistoric cow with characteristics of both primigenious and brachycerous cattle, „O554“, 9-11, pp. 53-72.
- Lasota-Moskalewska A., Kobryń H., Swiezyński K. 1987 Changes in the size of the domestic and wild pig in the territory of Poland from the Neolithic to the Middle Ages, ,,Acta Theriologica“, in press
- Sanev V. 1988 Neolithic Temple at tumba in Madjari, Skopje 1988 Region, preliminary report of the escavations in 1981, Maced, acta Archaeol. 9, Skopje 9-27.
- Schramm Z. 1967 Koésci dlugie a wysokosé w klebie и kozy, ,,Roczniki Wyzszej Szkoly Rolniczej w Poznaniu, 36, Schwartz C.A. 1976 The Vertebrate fauna from Rug Bair, In.:; Gimbutas M.: Neolithic Macedonia, Los Angeles, California, pp. 365-374.
- Teichert M. 1969 Untersuchungen zur Berechnung der Widerristhdhe bei vor-und friihgeschichtlichen Schweinen. Kihn-Archiv, 83, pp. 237-292.
- Wegrzynowicz T. 1982 Szcatki zwierzgce jako wyraz wierzen w czasach cialopalenia zwlok, Warszawa
- Zimmermann H. 1970 Urgeschichtliche opferfunde aus Fliissen, Mooren, Quellen und Brunnen Siidwestdeutschlands, Neue Ausgrabungen und Forschungen in Niedersachsen, 6, pp. 53-92.
- АЛИША ЛАСОТА МОСКАЛЕВСКА - Варшава
- ВОЈИСЛАВ САНЕВ - Скопје прелиминарна АНАЛИЗА НА ЖИВОТИНСКИТЕ КОСКЕНИ ОСТАТОЦИ ОД НЕОЛИТСКАТА НАСЕЛБА ТУМБА МАЏАРИ БЛИЗУ СКОПЈЕ (РЕЗИМЕ) Во последниве неколку2 години се вршат археозоолошки истражувања на неолитски наоѓалишта во СР3 Македонија . Овој труд е прва публикација од овој циклус на истражувања. Се однесува на остеолошкиот материјал од среднонеолитската населба Тумба во Маџари близу Скопје. откриен во нејзиниот последен хоризонт на живеење (III). Скоро сите остатоци имале консумен карактер. На тоа укажуваат бројните траги на коските, пред се трагите од сечење со остар предмет, што сугерира сечење на месо (сл. 1). Покрај тоа има и траги од контакти со висока температура (прегореност). Освен траги од ситнење на коските поврзано со консумирањето, најдени се траги и од намерна обработка. Од одделни фрагменти на коски или еленски рогови, со точење, или стружење биле правени орудија (сл. 2). Третиот тип траги на сечење сугерира напори сврзани со потребата од поседување на трофеи (рогови) од мали преживари или од култни побуди (сл. 3). Тие произлегуваат од истиот начин на отсекување на роговите од черепите на овците или козите. Роговите се сечени веднаш до коренот, заедно со мали фрагменти од черепот. За ова веројатно била употребувана остра и тешка алатка за што зачуваните траги оставаат впечаток на сечење со еден удар. Коскените остатоци се најдени на одредени места, во т.н. култни места или простори сврзани со куќите. Едно од тие е светилиште наменето за вршење на заеднички култни и религиозни обреди. Идентификувани се вкупно 2.847 остатоци од цицачи (таб. 1), потоа, 14 фрагменти од коски на скелет од човек, 4 коски од птици, 22 коски од риби и фрагменти од шлоки (Unio ѕр.). Од археозоолошката анализа произлегува констатацијата дека за неолитските жители на Тумба во Маџари основен извор на месо биле питомите цицачи, додека месото од дивите е дополнителна исхрана (5,520). Ловени се големи животни, пред се Typ, елен и дива свиња.
- Веројатно тие биле лесно достапни во природната околина на населбата, а покрај големото количество месо што било основна причина, ловењето на тур и дива свиња имало и дополнително значење: по убивањето на големото животно нивното малечко можело лесно да се фати и приспои кон домашните животни. Со оглед на добрите ефекти од припитомувањето тоа било и начин за зголемување на бројот на одгледуваните животни. Птиците не биле постојан извор на храна. Улогата на рибите е нејасна. Сепак, бројот на нивните остатоци е поголем во однос на остатоците од птици. Бидејќи се наједени на едно место, во јама со непозато значење (култно?), не треба да се сметаат како кујнски отпадоци. Присуството на фрагменти од школки- остриги може да се објасни како случајност, но може да биде и доказ за нивно ретко собирање од реките заради јадење или исхрана на свињите. Од питомите животни главен извор на храна биле преживарите, овцата и козата (48,1%) а исто така и говедата (41,1%). Се чини дека на прво место е одгледувањето на овцата. Соодносот на коските од овца со коските on коза изнесува 4,4:1. Таквиот сооднос се потврдува и во остеолошкиот материјал од
- Анзабегово (Bököny 1976) каде коски од овца имало шест пати повеќе отколку од коза. На овој локалитет од Источна Македонија. датиран во 6-5 милениум п.н.е, бројот4 на малите преживари бил значително поголем од говедата и свињите, поголем отколку во Маџари. Веројатно тоа е поврзано со постарото датирање на Анзабегово. Во врска со ова, веројатно таму сточар- ството доминирало над земјоделието, меѓутоа во Маџари тој сооднос е поизедначен. Популарноста на сточарството во Маџари се поврзува со земјоделско население, стабилизирано, кое имало ниви и пасишта со богата флора. За ова население, говедата биле услов за натамошен разиток, затоа што покрај изворот на месо и млеко, ги користеле и како работна сила, а давале и гној за наѓубрување на посевите. Што се однесува до свињите тие биле значително помалку одгледувани (10,6%). Остатоци на коски од куче има сосема малку (0,695). Овците во Маџари биле со мала и средна големина, многу2 помали од
- Анзабегово. Тие се разликуваат морфолошки што може да сведочи за различен степен на нивната припитоменост. Обично се вели дека европските овци и кози се дојдени од Југозападна
- Азија, на почетокот на неолитот. Во материјалот од Маџари најдени се неколку2 фрагменти од коски за кои е сомнително дека потекнуваат од малите диви преживари, а многу потсеќаат на коските на муфлон. За жал, тие не се толку карактеристични за да бидеме сигурни во оценката за постоењето на дивата овца во неолитска Македонија. Припитомувањето на говедата и свињите изгледа поинаку. Дивата форма на говеда, односно тур, била бројно присутна во Македонија. Ова е потврдено преку Маџари и Анзабегово. Големината на туровите, на двата локалитети е слична. Се појавуваат две групи: една е слична со големината на домашното говедо, другата е малку поголема. Ова може да биде поврзано со половиот диморфизам, но исто така може да произлегува од поделбата на туровите на вистински и преодни форми помеѓу2 дивото и припитоменото говедо. Домашното говедо во Маџари повеќе било различно во поглед на големината (сл. 4, цртеж 1). Доминирало говедото со средна големина и поголемо од таа. Слична разлика постоела и во Анзабегово. Оваа разлика сигурно произлегува од различниот степен на припитомување. Во материја- лот од Маџари посебно внимание привлекува многу12 малото говедо кое се издвојува од другите групи. Се работи за посебен тип на џуџесто говедо, чие откривање во Африка го опишал Epstein во 1971 г. Меѓутоа, тешко е да се каже дали ова говедо дошло во неолитска Македонија од другите простори или пак настанало локално. Во Тумба Маџари свињата заземала најниска позиција во стопанстово.
- Исто како и во Анзабегово не била многу2 популарна. На тлото на Македонија таа е локално припитомена. За тоа сведочи релативно бројното количество коски од дива свиња, како резултат на честото ловење. Но сепак, посилен аргумент е наоѓањето на посредни форми меѓу2 дивата и питомата свиња.
- Питомата свиња била чувана изолирана од природната околина и затоа таа е значително помала (цртеж 2). Питомите свињи се чувани кусо време, биле порано убивани одошто преживарите, за што сведочи големиот број на коски од млади свињи (таблица 3). Ова е сосема јасно ако се има предвид дека единствената цел на нивното чување било добивањето месо. Во остеолошкиот материјал од Маџари е направена споредбена анализа на бројот на врстите коски најдени во куќите (2, 3 и 4), а исто така и во просторот околу нив. Се покажа дека тие не се хомогени во поглед на количеството остатоци од говедо, свиња, овца и коза (таблица 2). Во куќите, статистички е потврден значително поголем број коски од овца и коза и недостаток на коски од свиња. Ова, во консумен поглед, тешко може да се објасни, бидејќи нема повод за сомнение дека некои врсти животни се јаделе во куќата, а други надвор. Ако овие два факта се гледаат заедно, може да се претпостави дека во куќите биле приложувани жртви во вид на горење животни. Жртвени животни можеле да бидат овци или евенутално кози, така што изгорените остатоци останувале внатре. Треба да се потцрта дека во т.н. светилште жртвените места и нивната најбилиска околина, прусуството на остатоци од овца и коза е значително поголемо. Таму, кај многу случаи се забележани траги од сечење на роговите од черепи, токму на овие две врсти животни. Овој факт, поврзан со погоре кажаното, може да се објасни само како култен обред. Литературата често опишува слични обредни обичаи, применувани кон животни поврзани со разни култови. Тие се однесуваат на цела Европа и тоа не само за неолитот туку2 и за подоцнежните епохи (Behrens
- 1965; Lasota - Moskalewska 1977; Wegrzykowicz 1982.). Идните континуирани археолошки истражувања на населбата Тумба во Маџари сигурно ќе помог- нат да се разрешат зацртаните проблеми во овој труд.